Chapter 22 - Cornered in the Deposition

Ten days later, the high-stakes confrontation moved into a ninth-floor deposition suite at the Dirksen Federal Building in downtown Chicago.
The room smelled of stale legal parchment and industrial floor wax. Sitting on one side of the long conference table was Arthur Sterling—a sharp-featured attorney wearing a gaudy pinstripe suit and an arrogant smirk that reminded me uncomfortably of Marcus Vale. Beside him sat Lauren.
She wore a modest gray pantsuit that looked slightly too big for her frame. Her face was drawn, her posture defensive, and she kept her gaze glued to the polished wood table, completely avoiding eye contact with me or Maya, who sat directly across from her alongside Nathan Cross.
A certified federal court reporter sat at the end of the table, fingers hovering over her stenotype machine.
"We are on the record," Nathan Cross announced cleanly. "This is the deposition of Lauren Miller in the matter of Vale v. Midwest Logistics Corporation. Witness was sworn by the reporter."
Arthur Sterling leaned forward, tapping a gold pen against his notepad. "Let the record reflect that Ms. Miller is appearing under subpoena, and we reserve all rights regarding executive privilege."
"There is no executive privilege for corporate fraud, Mr. Sterling," Nathan countered smoothly. He turned his attention to Lauren. "Ms. Miller, please state your current employment."
"Assistant shift supervisor at HomeGoods in Naperville," Lauren whispered.
"Please speak up so the reporter can hear you," Nathan instructed gently.
"Assistant supervisor at HomeGoods," she repeated, her voice cracking slightly.
"Thank you. Now, Ms. Miller, referring to Exhibit C of the plaintiff's complaint—an affidavit alleging that senior operations staff instructed you to delete vendor correspondence in November of two years ago. Did you provide the factual basis for that allegation?"
Lauren’s hands gripped her legal pad so tightly her knuckles turned white. She glanced sideways at Sterling, who offered an encouraging, subtle nod.
"I... I had conversations with Mr. Sterling regarding my recollection of that period," she stammered.
"That wasn't my question," Nathan pressed, his voice tightening with clinical precision. "Did Daniel Miller, or anyone acting under his instruction, ever direct you to delete, conceal, or alter any corporate records regarding Apex Creative and Marcus Vale?"
Sterling cut in immediately. "Objection. The witness is not an attorney and cannot interpret corporate compliance directives."
"I'm not asking for a legal interpretation, Mr. Sterling. I am asking for a statement of historical fact," Nathan retorted, turning back to Lauren. "Ms. Miller, answer the question. Did Daniel Miller instruct you to destroy records?"
The room fell dead silent. You could hear the faint clicking of the stenographer's keys recording the pause.
Lauren’s breathing became rapid and shallow. She looked up, her eyes finally colliding with mine. For a fleeting second, I saw the ghost of the woman I had loved for eleven years—conflicted, overwhelmed, and cornered by her own disastrous choices. But behind her sat the cold reality of her current existence: buried in debt, stripped of prestige, and manipulated once again by a slick attorney who viewed her as nothing more than a disposable pawn.
"Ms. Miller," Nathan warned, his tone dropping into a deadly, quiet register. "Before you answer, let me remind you that on November 14th of two years ago, you signed a court-approved criminal settlement containing a strict truthfulness clause. If you make a material misrepresentation under oath today, our office will file a criminal perjury referral with the State's Attorney before five o'clock this afternoon. Your deferred prosecution agreement will be revoked, and you will be remanded into custody."
Sterling slammed his gold pen onto the table. "This is witness intimidation! Counsel is harassing my client!"
"Counsel is stating federal law," Nathan replied without blinking. "Answer the question, Lauren."
Lauren’s lower lip began to tremble violently. A single tear broke free, trailing down her pale cheek. She looked at Sterling, who was glaring at her with furious expectation, and then looked back at me.
"No," Lauren choked out, her voice barely audible.
Sterling’s eyes widened in shock. "Lauren! What are you doing?!"
"NO!" Lauren shouted, suddenly breaking down into hysterical sobs, burying her face in her hands. "Daniel never told me to delete anything! He never touched my accounts! He didn't even know Marcus was pitching those vendor contracts until Maya caught the discrepancies!"
Sterling scrambled to gather his papers, his face turning an angry crimson. "We are taking a ten-minute recess! The witness is emotionally incapacitated!"
"The witness has testified under oath on the federal record," Nathan said, rising to his feet with absolute authority. "Ms. Miller, did Marcus Vale or Arthur Sterling promise you financial compensation from any potential settlement in this matter?"
"Sterling told me I would get twenty-five thousand dollars!" Lauren cried, pointing an accusing finger at her own attorney. "He said Daniel's company was terrified of bad press before their merger! He said if I just signed the draft statement, Daniel would settle out of court and my restitution debt would be wiped out!"
"That is privileged communication!" Sterling roared, shoving his chair back. "This deposition is terminated!"
"It certainly is," Nathan smiled thinly, closing his leather folio with a resounding snap. "And our next stop is the Illinois Attorney Registration and Disciplinary Commission to file disbarment proceedings against you for suborning perjury, followed by an immediate motion for sanctions and attorney's fees."
Sterling grabbed his briefcase and bolted from the deposition suite without uttering another word, leaving Lauren sobbing alone at the empty table.
Maya and I stood up. We didn't gloat. We didn't lecture her.
As we walked toward the heavy oak door, Lauren looked up through her tear-soaked lashes, her voice a ragged, desperate whisper.
"Daniel... I'm sorry. I'm so sorry. I didn't want to do it... I just... I couldn't breathe under the payments..."
I stopped at the doorway, looking back at her one last time.
May you like
"You keep looking for shortcuts, Lauren," I said quietly. "First it was Marcus, now it was Sterling. Until you learn to take honest responsibility for your life, you will spend every single day running from one disaster into another."
I turned, took Maya’s hand, and walked out into the corridor. The door clicked shut behind us, leaving the echoes of Lauren's weeping buried deep within the halls of justice.