Chapter 8 - The Truth Noah Demanded

Noah continued to fight for another minute, his fists pounding uselessly against Daniel's forearms, his body shuddering with violent, primal screams. But Daniel held him in an iron lock, absorbing every blow, burying his face into Noah’s wet hair.
Eventually, the fight drained out of the boy.
Noah collapsed into Daniel's chest, his hands gripping Daniel's forearms, his body curling inward as he began to sob with the desperate, unbridled agony of a broken child.
""Why didn't you want me?"" Noah wept, his voice muffled against Daniel's chest. ""When you saw that paper... why did you hate me?""
""I never hated you, Noah,"" Daniel choked out, his own tears blinding him. He rocked the seventeen-year-old boy in the cold Ohio mud, oblivious to the rain, the dirt, and the howling wind. ""I could never hate you. Never. Not for a single second of my life.""
""You left,"" Noah sobbed. ""You walked out.""
""Because I was a coward,"" Daniel confessed, his voice breaking. ""Because my heart was broken in half, and I didn't know how to look at you without feeling like a failure. I thought... I thought God had cheated me. But God didn't cheat me, Noah. God gave me you.""
A few yards away, Ryan stood in the rain, watching the two of them. He kept his distance, a silent, grieving sentry who knew his place.
Noah slowly lifted his head from Daniel's chest. He looked at Daniel's face—streaked with grime, rain, and unconditional love.
""Tell me the truth, Dad,"" Noah pleaded, his voice shaking. ""Everything. No more secrets. No more protecting anyone. Tell me what happened.""
Daniel nodded slowly. He helped Noah sit up, but kept one arm firmly around the boy's shoulders, shielding him from the wind.
""Seventeen years ago,"" Daniel said, ""your mother and I were drowning in grief. We had lost babies. We thought our marriage was over. I went away to work because I couldn't bear to see her cry anymore. And I left your Uncle Ryan behind to look after the house.""
Daniel looked over at Ryan, whose head was bowed.
""They made a terrible mistake, Noah. One night. That’s all it was. It wasn't an affair. It wasn't love. It was two desperate, lonely people who broke under the weight of their pain. Ryan left the very next morning because he couldn't live with what he had done to his brother.""
Daniel turned Noah’s face toward his own.
""Three weeks later, I came home. And when your mother got pregnant, we both thought it was a miracle. We thought you were mine. Ryan thought you were mine. Your mother convinced herself you were mine. For seventeen years, we all lived that truth.""
""Until the blood test,"" Noah whispered.
""Until the blood test,"" Daniel agreed. ""And when I saw that paper, Noah, I felt like someone had erased seventeen years of my life. I went to Cleveland to hurt Ryan. I wanted to destroy him.""
""Did you?"" Noah asked quietly, looking at Ryan's bruised jaw.
""I tried,"" Daniel said. ""And then I realized something while I was sitting on Ryan's floor. That paper told me I didn't give you your DNA. But that paper didn't teach you how to swim the butterfly stroke. That paper didn't stay up with you until 2:00 AM helping you study for your AP History exams. That paper didn't hold your hand when you were terrified of the dark.""
Daniel grabbed Noah's face in both of his rough, calloused hands, forcing Noah to look directly into his eyes.
""A father is not a donor, Noah. A father is the man who shows up every single day of your life and chooses you. I chose you the day you were born. I chose you yesterday. And I am choosing you right now in this damn mud.""
Noah stared at Daniel, his lip trembling. ""Even if I look like him?""
Daniel swallowed hard. He looked at Ryan, standing twenty feet away in the rain, then looked back at Noah.
""You have his crooked smile,"" Daniel admitted honestly, a tear cutting through the dirt on his cheek. ""And you have his rebellious streak. But your heart, Noah? The way you care about people? The way you protect your friends? That didn't come from a lab. That came from this family. You are a Bennett. You will always be my son.""
May you like
Noah let out a ragged, shuddering breath and threw his arms around Daniel’s neck, burying his face in his father’s shoulder. Daniel wrapped his arms around him, pulling him tight against his chest, closing his eyes against the storm.
Behind them, Ryan wiped a sleeve across his wet face, let out a silent, broken sob of gratitude, and looked up at the clearing sky.