Chapter 87 - The Other Child at the Table

Caleb ate half the pancakes before speaking.
I let him.
Outside the diner window, a delivery truck blocked the morning sunlight. Somebody at the counter complained about the price of eggs. The waitress called everyone honey without making it sound like a diagnosis.
“Do you think Dad wishes he found her sooner?” Caleb asked.
“Yes.”
“Then he wishes everything was different.”
I put down my fork.
“That doesn’t automatically mean he wishes you away.”
“Automatically.”
He caught the word instantly.
“I’m not inside his head,” I said. “I won’t pretend I am.”
Caleb nodded, though it was not the reassurance he wanted.
He told me Eric had missed a pickup after Ruby’s advocate requested an urgent meeting. Allison had collected him instead. Nobody had left him stranded, but his father’s absence had landed where every recent fear already lived.
“I know Ruby needs him,” he said. “I’m not a jerk.”
“Needing your dad doesn’t make you one.”
He looked down.
“I was the kid Grandma liked. Maybe now I’m getting what I deserve.”
The diner seemed to go quiet around us.
“No,” I said.
He glanced up.
“You were a child. You didn’t design the family. You’re responsible for the choices you make now, not for having been treated differently when you were little.”
His mouth trembled once. He hid it behind the water glass.
I stayed still until he put it down. For once, he had nothing he needed to defend.
Before leaving the diner, Caleb asked whether Ruby had known about him. I said he would have to ask her, because I did not know. He nodded and folded his napkin into smaller squares. Then he admitted he had searched her name online and found a photograph from a school art display. She looked happy in it. That had upset him in a way he could not explain. I suggested that seeing someone’s life before a crisis could make them harder to imagine as a problem with one label. He considered that. Then he said she drew buildings better than people. I told him that sounded like a perfectly safe place to begin a conversation. He slipped the folded napkin into his pocket instead of leaving it on the plate.
When we returned, Eric was waiting by his truck.
I asked Caleb whether he wanted me nearby. He said yes, but not close enough to hear everything.
I sat on the porch while they walked to the orchard.
Later, Eric told me he had apologized for the missed pickup without explaining why Ruby’s meeting mattered more.
He had put the next four father-and-son afternoons on a shared calendar and asked Caleb what he wanted to do.
“Basketball,” Eric said, sounding astonished. “He wanted basketball.”
“Did you expect a major expedition?”
“I think I expected him to ask for something I could buy.”
I looked at my brother.
He gave a miserable smile.
“Still learning.”
Meanwhile, Ruby became certain Caleb hated her.
He was polite and careful, which she interpreted as dislike because she had spent years learning to distrust anything rehearsed.
Maisie finally lost patience with both of them.
“You’re allowed to be awkward,” she said at dinner. “You don’t have to turn it into a mystery.”
Caleb glared at her.
Ruby laughed before she could stop herself.
The sound startled everyone.
Caleb looked at her, then smiled reluctantly.
After dinner, they argued about music while drying plates. I heard them disagree without either one retreating, and some small pressure eased in my chest.
The next afternoon, Maisie received an acceptance email for a residential summer art intensive in another state.
She had applied months before Ruby arrived.
Nicole screamed loud enough to bring Dad running from the garden.
I hugged my daughter so hard she complained about her ribs.
Then Ruby went quiet.
That night, Maisie knocked on our bedroom door.
“I don’t think I should go.”
Nicole moved aside on the bed.
“Why?”
“Ruby just got here. Grandpa’s tired all the time. You’re both stressed.”
May you like
I looked at my daughter, holding an opportunity she had worked for as though it were something stolen.
“Maisie,” I said, “when did you start thinking this family was your job?”