Chapter 3 - Forty-Three Openings

Grace Wallace called Hannah on Monday morning.
She introduced herself as the privacy officer for the organization that operated Northside.
Her voice was steady, neither reassuring too quickly nor treating my daughter as an inconvenience.
Hannah asked me to join the call.
Grace confirmed that permission before continuing.
It was a small thing.
After the weekend, small things had become visible.
“We’re reviewing access associated with your chart,” she said. “We also want to confirm the permissions on your patient portal.”
Linda had no authorized proxy access.
Josh had no separate portal account linked to Hannah’s records either.
He sometimes helped her look at information when she handed him her phone.
That did not mean his mother was entitled to it.
Grace asked whether Hannah had signed any forms allowing Linda to assist with care.
“There was a payment form,” Hannah said. “She helped with an early bill.”
“Do you have a copy?”
“I think so.”
“Please send it through the secure link I’ll provide.”
When the call ended, Hannah exhaled.
“She didn’t ask why I was making trouble.”
“No,” I said.
“She didn’t tell me Linda was probably worried.”
“No.”
I heard a drawer open on her end.
Then papers moving.
A few minutes later, she sent me the form.
It allowed the clinic to discuss a specified billing balance with Linda.
Nothing about clinical results.
Nothing about appointments generally.
Nothing about unrestricted access.
I looked at the date.
New Year’s Day.
The day Linda had offered to make everything easier.
That evening, Josh came to our house alone.
He stood on the porch holding a grocery bag.
“I brought the soup Hannah likes.”
“She’s not here.”
“I know. She asked if she could come over later. I thought—”
He stopped.
Dan took the bag.
“Come inside.”
Josh looked miserable.
I had once found his discomfort reassuring.
It suggested he was kind.
Now I understood that a person could feel terrible about a problem and still leave someone else trapped inside it.
“Did you give your mother Hannah’s password?” I asked.
“No.”
“Did you send her appointment notes?”
“Not records. Sometimes I told her how appointments went.”
“With Hannah’s permission?”
He swallowed.
“Not always.”
Dan pulled out a chair.
Josh sat.
“She’d ask if everything was okay. I thought I was reassuring her.”
“And Hannah?”
He looked at me.
“What?”
“Who was reassuring Hannah?”
His eyes filled.
I didn’t enjoy that.
I also didn’t rescue him from the question.
Three days later, Grace contacted Hannah again.
This time, she confirmed something more substantial.
Linda had recently returned to Northside under a temporary administrative contract.
She had not told us.
Her assigned work involved patient outreach and unresolved administrative tasks.
The system access attached to her role had been broader than it should have been.
The review had identified access to Hannah’s chart under Linda’s credentials.
“How many times?” Hannah asked.
Grace paused.
“The preliminary review shows forty-three chart openings over several months. We’re still determining the purpose and scope of each.”
Hannah’s face changed.
We were sitting at my kitchen table, the phone between us.
“Forty-three?”
“I understand that is upsetting.”
“Was she supposed to be in my chart?”
“We have not identified a work-related reason for the access we’ve reviewed so far.”
I watched my daughter go very still.
Forty-three openings.
Not an accidental click.
Not one anxious moment.
A repeated decision.
Grace explained that Linda’s access had been suspended while the review continued.
She asked Hannah not to confront anyone on behalf of the investigation or try to obtain internal records herself.
Hannah agreed.
Then she asked, “Did she see the test result before the cookout?”
“The relevant result was available in the chart before that event. We’re reviewing the timing of access.”
It was careful language.
It was enough.
After the call, Hannah pushed her chair back.
“I thought I was forgetting things.”
My heart hurt.
“She kept saying I’d told her. And Josh said maybe I had. And you said she meant well.”
“Yes.”
Hannah pressed both hands against the table.
“I started writing conversations down.”
I had no answer that could make that smaller.
So I said the truth.
“I should have believed you.”
She looked at me for a long time.
Then she slid a notebook across the table.
May you like
On the first page, beside a date in April, she had written:
I know I did not tell her.