Chapter 5 - A Father’s Desperate Clue

The following morning, we returned to my parents' home while we waited for the preliminary blood screening results. Caleb refused to leave the nursery my mother had hastily arranged in the guest bedroom. He sat in the rocking chair for hours, holding Nora against his bare chest for skin-to-skin contact, his face etched with a mixture of profound devotion and gut-wrenching remorse.
""I don't expect you to forgive me, Clara,"" he said softly, his voice rough from lack of sleep as I brought him a cup of coffee. ""What I did at the hospital... throwing your clothes on the porch... it was unforgivable. I turned into a monster because I was terrified of being broken again. If you want to divorce me after we make sure Nora is healthy, I won't fight you. I'll give you everything. I just want to be allowed to love her for whatever time we have.""
I sat on the edge of the bed, watching the man I loved crumble beneath the weight of generational trauma. ""I’m not thinking about divorce or staying together right now, Caleb. My only priority is keeping our daughter alive. But your mother is hiding something about Julianna's death. You saw her face when Dr. Vance mentioned the state archives. She wasn't just grieving; she was terrified of what those files contain.""
Caleb frowned, looking up from Nora’s sleeping form. ""My mom loved Julianna more than life itself. She kept her nursery untouched for five years after she died. What could she possibly be hiding?""
""Think about it,"" I pressed gently. ""Why did she reinforce your fear in the delivery room? The moment you panicked and said Nora wasn't the baby you wanted, Margaret didn't try to calm you down. She clicked her tongue, agreed with you, and encouraged you to walk away from us. It was like she wanted this curse to be real. She wanted you to flee.""
Caleb's eyes widened as the realization settled into his thoughts. He reached into his pocket and pulled out his phone. ""My father died when I was twelve, but he kept an old metal lockbox in the attic of my childhood home. Margaret always told me it only held old tax returns and deed papers for their first plot of land. But I have the key on my key ring. He gave it to me right before he passed away in the hospice ward.""
Without wasting another minute, Caleb called my dad to watch over Nora and me, and sped across town to his mother's house while Margaret was at the local church attending her weekly prayer group.
An hour later, Caleb returned, his face pale and his hands trembling violently. In his arms, he carried a rusted gray metal lockbox. He placed it on my father's dining room table and inserted the small brass key. The lock clicked open with a harsh, metallic snap.
Inside, beneath bundles of yellowed mortgage receipts and vehicle titles from 1988, lay a thick manila envelope sealed with faded red wax. Printed across the front in official black lettering were the words: Commonwealth of Kentucky – Office of the Chief Medical Examiner – Case No. 89-C-0412.
May you like
Caleb broke the seal with a trembling thumb. As he pulled out the brittle pages and began reading the official findings from August 1989, his breath hitched in his throat. His knees buckled, and he dropped into the nearest chair as if struck by a physical hammer.
""Clara..."" Caleb whispered, his voice barely audible above the hum of the refrigerator. ""Julianna didn't die from an inherited genetic disease. The coroner's report says her heart was completely normal.""