Chapter 6 - The Church Basement Reckoning

The basement of St. Paul’s Lutheran Church smelled of damp concrete, floor wax, and sixty years of potluck suppers. It was the exact same room where, two months earlier, Randy had pushed a five-hundred-thousand-dollar check across a folding table while Jeff’s casket was still fresh in the cemetery dirt.
Tonight, the fluorescent lights hummed overhead, casting a sterile, unforgiving glare across the linoleum floor.
On one side of the long folding table sat Randy and Scott, flanked by Arthur Vance, a slick corporate attorney they had driven in from Grand Island. Randy looked haggard; his eyes were bloodshot, his collar unbuttoned, his fingers drumming an erratic, nervous rhythm against a leather briefcase. Scott sat beside him, pale and silent, staring down at his knuckles.
On the other side of the table sat Evelyn, Luke, and me. Beside me sat Abby, quiet but composed, still clutching her father's seed cap on her lap like a shield.
Between us lay the contents of the Hastings bank lockbox: a thick, leather-bound journal written entirely in Jeff’s unmistakable, rugged handwriting, complete with the jagged hitch in his capital letters, accompanied by a dozen certified banking slips and a notarized addendum to the partnership agreement dated one week before his death.
""This meeting is irregular,"" Arthur Vance began, clearing his throat and adjusting his gold-rimmed glasses. ""My clients have acted entirely within the legal bounds of the Miller Brothers partnership agreement. The five-hundred-thousand-dollar buyout paid to Mrs. Melissa Miller was fully executed. Any claims of impropriety regarding agricultural investments are internal corporate matters that do not concern external parties.""
""Shut up, Arthur,"" Evelyn said. The tone was so quiet, so filled with absolute authority, that the high-priced attorney closed his mouth instantly.
Evelyn pushed the leather-bound journal across the table toward Randy.
""Read page forty-two, Randy,"" she commanded. ""Read it out loud so your daughter-in-law and your granddaughter can hear what your brother thought of you before he died.""
Randy’s hands shook as he touched the worn leather. He opened the book. The handwriting was unmistakable.
""'February 18,'"" Randy read, his voice catching in his throat, barely more than a ragged rasp. ""'Discovered Randy’s unhedged short positions on the CBOT account. Four hundred and ten thousand dollars gone. Met with Randy and Scott in the machine shed. Randy begged me not to tell Mama. He swore he could trade his way back before the spring fertilizer bills came due. I told him that theft is theft, even when it's done by a brother. I told him I would give him until June first to sell the south quarter and repay the corporate account, or I would dissolve the partnership myself and hand the books to the federal bank examiners.'""
Randy stopped reading. A heavy, suffocating silence fell over the church basement.
""Jeff knew,"" I said, leaning forward until Randy was forced to look into my eyes. ""He was trying to save you from prison, Randy. He was giving you a chance to sell personal land to cover your gambling debts so the century farm wouldn't be lost. And how did you repay him? The night before he died, you cornered him in that shed, screamed at him until his heart gave out, and then before his body was even cold, you forged his signature to take out another loan to cover your tracks.""
""I was trying to save the farm!"" Randy suddenly exploded, slamming his open palms onto the table with a crash that rattled the metal legs. ""You don't understand the pressure, Melissa! The fertilizer prices tripled! Diesel went to five dollars a gallon! The banks were squeezing our lines of credit! I made a bad call on the futures market trying to make enough profit to buy out the north section! If the bank foreclosed, three generations of work would have vanished overnight! I did what I had to do to keep the Miller name on those elevators!""
""No, Randy,"" Luke interrupted, his voice cutting through his father’s hysteria like a razor. ""You did what you had to do to keep your name on that brand-new four-wheel-drive combine. You did it because you couldn't stand the thought of people at the co-op knowing that Uncle Jeff was the real brains behind this operation and you were just an arrogant gambler.""
Randy slumped back in his chair, breathing heavily, looking like a man whose parachute had failed to open at ten thousand feet.
Arthur Vance leaned over to Randy, whispered something urgent in his ear, then looked across the table at me. ""What are your terms, Mrs. Miller? Assuming these documents possess legal validity in an equity audit, what is it that you want?""
I looked at Abby, then at Luke, and finally at Evelyn.
""I don't want Randy or Scott in prison,"" I said clearly.
Randy looked up, genuine shock flickering across his hollow face.
""Not because you don't deserve it,"" I continued ruthlessly. ""You deserve ten years in a federal cell. But because your father’s name is carved on that church cornerstone outside, and because Jeff loved this town too much to see our family name dragged through a public criminal trial. Here are my terms: Randy and Scott will sign over their entire personal equity in the Miller Brothers partnership to Evelyn and Luke. You will surrender all management authority. You will retain a minority ten percent non-voting dividend, which will barely cover your living expenses in town. The eighty acres across the road—the Wiebe place—will be transferred deed-free to Abby as her rightful inheritance. And Luke takes over as general manager of the entire twelve hundred acres starting tomorrow morning.""
May you like
Scott gasped. ""You’re stripping us of everything! We built this operation!""
""You almost destroyed it,"" Evelyn said coldly. ""Sign the transfer papers, boys. Or Sheriff Peterson walks through those double doors with the state troopers waiting outside in the parking lot.""