solutions

Chapter 6 - The Rehearsal Dinner Mutiny

The rehearsal dinner took place at an upscale Italian restaurant in Short North, Columbus, the evening before the wedding. The private dining room was adorned with warm candlelight, polished mahogany tables, and bouquets of white lilies that Hannah had personally arranged for us. Tyler’s parents had generously paid for the entire evening, wanting to welcome both families in a spirit of celebration.

Yet from the moment my parents and Madison walked through the brass-trimmed doors, the tension was palpable. Madison was draped in a designer trench coat, pouting because parking had been difficult to find. Mom swept into the room, barely greeting Tyler’s parents before scanning the tables with an eagle eye.

“Where is the head table?” Mom demanded, turning toward me. “Madison needs to be seated directly between you and Tyler so she can assist with the speeches.”

“The bridal party is seated together at the center table, Linda,” Tyler’s mother, Susan, said politely, offering a cordial smile. “Emma and Tyler are seated at the sweetheart table at the front.”

Mom pursed her lips, clearly displeased that she hadn't dictated the seating chart. Throughout dinner, my family made their indifference painfully obvious. While Tyler’s groomsmen gave heartfelt, funny toasts recounting college memories and Tyler’s devotion to me, my father sat staring down at his phone, checking college football scores.

Finally, it was time for the maid of honor toast. Madison tapped her wine glass with a butter knife, standing up with an exaggerated sweep of her hair. She pulled a folded piece of paper from her clutch.

“Hi, everyone,” Madison began, smiling broadly at the room. “For those who don't know me, I’m Madison, Emma’s sister and the maid of honor. Most of you probably know me from my recent exhibition at the High Street Gallery.”

Hannah, seated next to Jess, quietly lowered her wine glass, exchanging a knowing glance with me.

“Growing up with Emma was... interesting,” Madison continued, chuckling at her own words. “Emma was always the quiet, sensible one—the girl who stayed in her room studying while I was out experiencing the world. Our parents always said I had the fire and Emma had the ice. When Tyler proposed, I was honestly shocked she managed to land someone so charming, because Emma has always struggled to make bold choices. But I suppose even plain canvases need a frame!”

A few uncomfortable titters echoed through the room, quickly silenced by the palpable awkwardness. Tyler’s father frowned deeply, while Tyler took my hand under the table, his grip protective and steady.

“Anyway,” Madison wrapped up casually, “I’m glad I could step in and make sure this wedding has some actual flair. Here’s to Emma and Tyler—and here’s to making sure tomorrow’s photos look fabulous. Cheers!”

She raised her glass, took a sip, and sat down, completely oblivious to the cold silence hanging in the room.

Mom beamed, leaning across the table to pat Madison’s hand. “Such a lovely, honest speech, darling. So creative.”

Dad cleared his throat, pushing his chair back. “Alright, Linda, let’s wrap this up. We have an early morning, and Richard needs his rest for tomorrow.”

He didn't offer a toast to me. He didn't thank Tyler’s parents for the exquisite meal. He simply stood up, ready to leave. As Mom grabbed her wrap, she leaned close to my ear, whispering in a low, venomous tone:

“I saw that Hannah helped arrange the table flowers instead of letting Madison’s florist friend handle them. You’re lucky Madison is so forgiving, Emma. If you cause any drama tomorrow about her gown, Richard and I will leave before the reception starts. Don't test us.”

May you like

I looked into my mother’s cold, calculated eyes. The little girl inside me who used to cry in her bedroom over a stolen doll finally vanished, replaced by an iron fortress of self-respect.

“Don't worry, Mom,” I whispered back with a serene smile. “Tomorrow will be unforgettable for all of us.”

Related Stories

Other posts