Chapter 8 - The Confrontation in the Interrogation Room

The air inside the Marion County Sheriff’s Department interrogation suite smelled of stale floor wax and cold institutional coffee. A single two-way mirror covered the south wall, reflecting the harsh fluorescent glare back onto the steel table where Chloe Montgomery sat.
Her designer jacket and jewelry had been stripped away, replaced by an oversized orange prison jumpsuit that swallowed her petite frame. But her eyes still held that dangerous, calculating glint. Her defense attorney, a slick local public defender she had demanded upon processing, sat beside her with a yellow legal pad, looking like a man who wished he were anywhere else on earth.
I pushed open the heavy steel door, carried two manila folders inside, and tossed them onto the table. The folders landed with a sharp, heavy slap that made Chloe’s attorney flinch.
“Agent Vance,” the attorney began nervously. “My client has invoked her right to remain silent until formal arraignment—”
“Your client can invoke whatever she wants,” I said, pulling out a metal folding chair and sitting down directly across from Chloe. “I’m not here to ask questions. I’m here to read the federal charges before the United States Attorney presents them to the grand jury at 1:00 p.m.”
Chloe leaned back, folding her cuffed arms across her chest with an icy, contemptuous smirk. “Go ahead, Maya. Read whatever fantasy you wrote. At the end of the day, it’s my word against a senile old man’s. The local judge will grant me bail, and I’ll be on a flight to Cabo before your trial even gets a docket number.”
“You won't be getting bail, Chloe,” I said softly.
I opened the first folder and slid an eight-by-ten glossy photograph across the table. It was an autopsy report from Hillsborough County, Florida, dated four years ago. The subject was Robert Sinclair, her first wealthy husband.
Chloe’s eyes flicked to the photo, and for a split second, the corners of her mouth twitched.
“Robert Sinclair died of what the local coroner ruled an acute coronary event,” I said, resting my forearms on the table. “However, an exhumation order was signed two hours ago by the Florida Circuit Court. Do you know why, Chloe? Because Dr. Warren Henderson confessed that he mailed you the exact same Haloperidol and digitalis compound back in 2022 that he gave you for my father last month.”
The smirk completely vanished from Chloe’s face.
I slid the second folder across the table. “Harold Vance in Reno. Another exhumation request is pending in Nevada. The Department of Justice has officially consolidated your cases into a multi-jurisdictional federal serial murder and financial fraud task force. You aren't being charged with elder abuse, Chloe. You are being charged under the Federal Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act, alongside two counts of premeditated capital murder.”
The public defender stared at the documents, his face turning pale. He slowly closed his yellow legal pad, slid his chair six inches away from Chloe, and whispered, “My God.”
“You... you’re bluffing,” Chloe stammered, her voice losing its icy composure for the first time. Her hands began to shake inside the steel cuffs. “You can’t connect those cases to me! It was years ago! The estates were settled!”
“Richard Sterling just gave us your private text logs from his encrypted server,” I continued relentlessly. “We have your voice notes discussing the dosage schedule. We have your bank wires splitting the proceeds. We have the cattle prod with your latent fingerprints and my father’s DNA burned into the contact prongs.”
I leaned forward until my face was barely a foot from hers.
“You thought my father was an easy mark because he was an old man living alone in a farmhouse,” I whispered, every word dripping with cold, unyielding justice. “You thought because you broke other families, you could break mine. But you forgot that my father spent his whole life teaching people the difference between right and wrong. And he raised a daughter who hunts monsters like you for a living.”
Chloe looked down at the autopsy photos of the men she had murdered. The cold, sociopathic mask finally fractured, revealing the trembling, terrified coward underneath. Her breathing turned shallow, and tears of pure, desperate self-pity began streaming down her cheeks.
“What... what do they want from me?” she sobbed.
“They want your full confession,” I said, standing up from the table. “Every property. Every accomplice. Every dollar you stole. Sign the plea, and the federal prosecutor might take the death penalty off the table in Florida. Refuse, and you spend the rest of your natural life in a supermax concrete box waiting for a lethal injection.”
May you like
I turned toward the door, knocking twice for the guard to unlock the latch.
“Enjoy the rest of your afternoon, Chloe,” I said without looking back. “It’s the last time you’ll ever see the sky without iron bars.”