solutions

Chapter 8 - The Question Beneath the Question

The setback came on an ordinary Tuesday.

Claire took Harper to a school orientation. Grant picked Mason up from baseball practice. On the way home, they stopped for dinner.

A waitress asked whether Mason was excited about getting a little sister.

Grant answered before thinking.

“He sure is.”

Mason put down his menu.

“No, I’m not.”

By the time Grant called me, Mason had asked to go to Olivia’s.

“I ruined it,” Grant said.

“What happened after he said no?”

“I told the waitress we were still figuring things out. Then I apologized in the car.”

“And?”

“He said Harper isn’t his little sister.”

“Did you argue?”

“No.”

“Good.”

Grant sounded exhausted.

“How long will every sentence feel like a trap?”

“Probably longer if you keep calling it a trap.”

He went quiet.

I softened my voice.

“He’s telling you what a word means to him. You can learn that.”

Two evenings later, Mason asked to come over.

He helped me pull weeds beneath the pecan tree, working with an intensity that threatened several innocent plants.

“Dad told you?”

“He told me dinner was difficult.”

“I like Harper sometimes.”

“That’s allowed.”

“I don’t want to call her my sister.”

“You don’t have to decide what to call her today.”

He dug at a stubborn root.

“What if everybody thinks I’m mean?”

“Then the adults can explain that families grow at different speeds.”

He sat back on his heels.

“Are they going to have a baby?”

The question had been waiting beneath everything else.

“Have you asked them?”

“No.”

“Why?”

“If they say yes, then there’ll be a real new little girl.”

I put my trowel down.

Harper could be told she had a different mother. A new baby would belong to Grant in a way Mason feared might fill the place Rosie had left.

I asked whether he wanted help starting the conversation.

He nodded.

We invited Grant and Claire over that Sunday.

Mason chose the porch because he said kitchens made things feel serious now.

When he asked his question, Claire didn’t glance at Grant for permission.

“We haven’t decided whether we’ll have a baby,” she said.

Mason’s fingers tightened around his lemonade.

“But we won’t ask you to promise you’ll be excited about something before you know how you feel.”

Grant leaned forward.

“And no child could replace Rosie.”

“What if it’s a girl?”

“Then she would be another person. She wouldn’t get Rosie’s birthday or her stories or the years we had with her.”

“What about her room?”

Grant took a breath.

“We don’t live in that house anymore.”

“I know.”

“But we can talk about her things before we make decisions about them. I should have done that already.”

Mason looked toward the tree.

“Can the yellow box stay mine?”

“Yes,” Grant said.

“Even if there’s a baby?”

“Yes.”

Claire added, “And you never have to share something just because it matters to someone else.”

Mason’s shoulders lowered a fraction.

That afternoon, Harper arrived with her grandmother.

She wanted to know why we were all sitting outside without snacks.

The adults laughed.

Mason got up and brought crackers.

A few minutes later, she asked him to help fix the clasp on her backpack.

He did.

She said thank you.

He said you’re welcome.

It was so ordinary that I almost cried.

Before leaving, Grant stopped beside the photograph on my mantel.

“I’m not ready for a wedding yet,” he told Claire.

She took his hand.

“I know.”

“But I want to be.”

“I know that too.”

Mason stood near the doorway, listening.

For once, nobody asked him to reassure them.

May you like

He picked up his backpack and went to the car.

On the way, he held the door open for Harper.

Related Stories

Other posts