Chapter 4 - A Very Uncomfortable Morning

The morning after Christmas brought brilliant winter sunshine that reflected blindingly off the fresh eight inches of snow.
At 412 Elm Street, Brandon woke up around eight o’clock, yawning loudly as he padded down the hallway in his flannel pajamas. In his mind, yesterday had been an awkward bump, but ultimately a victory. He had established authority. He had shown his mother that he was the undisputed king of his household. Evelyn had stormed off like an overly dramatic grandmother, but she always came around. She always brought over Tupperware containers of homemade soup by Tuesday, apologizing for being sensitive.
He wandered into the kitchen to start the espresso machine. The sink was piled high with the dirty dishes from last night’s feast. The roasting pan was encrusted with dried meat juices, and three empty bottles of Donna’s expensive cabernet sat unrinsed on the granite island.
“Claire!” he called out toward the stairs, irritation bleeding into his voice. “Why hasn't the kitchen been cleared yet? Matthew and Sarah will be awake in an hour, and Mom expects a proper breakfast.”
Claire walked into the kitchen wearing a faded robe. Her eyes were puffy, dark circles bruising the skin beneath them. She hadn't slept a wink.
“I didn't have the energy, Brandon,” she said quietly, her voice flat and drained. “The kids were crying last night because Mom wasn’t here to read them their Christmas Eve story. They refused to go to sleep until past midnight.”
“Oh, spare me the theatrics,” Brandon scoffed, pressing the button on the grinder. “Your mother threw a childish tantrum because an older woman with spinal issues needed a comfortable chair. She’ll be here by noon with groceries, mark my words. She can’t stand being away from the kids for more than twenty-four hours. She needs this family far more than we need her.”
Footsteps shuffled down the staircase. Donna Whitaker appeared in the kitchen doorway, wrapped in an elegant cashmere robe that Brandon had bought her on credit three weeks earlier. She carried an air of wounded martyrdom, sighing loudly as she pulled a stool up to the island.
“I still feel dreadful about last night, Brandon,” Donna murmured, pressing a delicate hand to her forehead. “If I had known your mother-in-law was so territorial about a simple wooden chair, I would have gladly sat on the floor. I hope I haven’t ruined your family dynamic.”
“Don’t apologize, Mom,” Brandon said firmly, handing her a freshly brewed latte with perfect foam. “You are my mother. This is my house. You will sit wherever I say you sit. In fact, Matthew and I talked late last night while Claire was upstairs. There is no reason for you to go back to Ohio and waste two thousand dollars a month on that miserable apartment. We have four bedrooms here. Evelyn rarely uses the large den downstairs anyway. We can convert it into a lovely in-law suite for you by spring.”
Claire froze by the refrigerator, a carton of milk suspended in mid-air.
“You did what?” Claire whispered, her voice shaking with disbelief. “Brandon, that den was my father’s library. My mother still has all of his books and photo albums stored there. You didn't even ask me!”
“I don’t need to ask permission to take care of my own flesh and blood, Claire,” Brandon snapped, turning on her with a hardened glare. “We have plenty of square footage. Your mother lives five miles away in a perfectly good cottage. She doesn’t need two rooms here to collect dust. It’s settled. Mom is moving in by the end of January.”
Donna smiled a small, satisfied smile behind the rim of her coffee mug. “You are such a wonderful son, Brandon. A true provider.”
Before Claire could utter another word, a sharp, authoritative knock echoed from the heavy oak front door.
Brandon chuckled dismissively, adjusting his sweater. “See? What did I tell you? There’s Evelyn now, right on schedule. Watch this, Mom. She’s probably bringing a fresh pie as an olive branch.”
Brandon strutted down the hallway, pulling open the heavy wooden door with an arrogant grin prepared on his lips.
“Well, Evelyn, I hope you’ve had time to think about—”
May you like
He stopped dead.
Standing on the porch was not a contrite, seventy-one-year-old grandmother carrying baked goods. Standing on the porch was a tall, stoic man in a heavy charcoal overcoat holding a formal legal briefcase, flanked by a uniformed county sheriff’s deputy holding a clipboard.