Chapter 3 - The Ghost from the Past
The silence in the basement grew heavy, suffocating, and impossibly deep, broken only by the distant, rhythmic dripping of a leaky pipe somewhere in the darkness.
"Please," Dominic said again, his voice dropping to a fragile whisper that sounded entirely foreign coming from a man built for violence.
Against every instinct screaming at me to run, to fight, to protect myself, something in his tone dismantled my defenses. Slowly, painfully, wincing as the bruised muscles in my back protested, I shifted my weight and turned my body slightly to the side, pulling the torn collar of my shirt away from my left shoulder.
Exposed to the harsh light of the bare bulb was a mark I had carried for as long as I could remember.
It was a faded, keloidal scar roughly the size of a silver dollar. A pale, raised circle burned permanently into the skin, neatly divided down the center by three uneven, jagged lines, with a tiny, distinct notch carved into its lower edge. To anyone else, it looked like a crude, deformed brand or a terrible childhood accident with boiling water.
Dominic stopped breathing.
I watched him stare at it, his chest motionless beneath his wool coat, his dark eyes wide and unblinking. He looked as though he were staring at a ghost rising from the grave.
Then, his lips parted, and he breathed a single name into the cold air.
"Emily."
I twisted back around, letting the torn fabric snap back over my shoulder, my face contorted in a mixture of confusion and sudden rage.
"What did you just call me?" I demanded, my voice echoing off the concrete walls.
Dominic’s gaze remained fixed on the spot where the mark had been, as if he could still see it burning through the cloth. "My sister."
I shook my head vigorously, backing up another inch until my shoulders collided painfully with the brick. "You’re out of your mind. My name is Nora. Nora Bell. I grew up in the foster system upstate, bouncing from one miserable group home to another until I was eighteen. I don't have a brother, and I certainly don't know any mafia bosses!"
"My sister had that exact mark," Dominic said, his voice dropping into a hollow, haunted register.
"People get burned, accidents happen—"
"Not that mark," Dominic interrupted fiercely, taking a sudden step forward. "Not a circle divided by three intersecting lines with a notch at the base. That wasn't an accident, Nora. That was a signature."
A cold shudder raced down my spine, freezing the blood in my veins. "What are you talking about?"
"She disappeared fourteen years ago," Dominic murmured, looking up to meet my eyes, his own gaze swimming with a raw, agonizing vulnerability that no enemy had ever managed to draw out of him. "She was ten years old. I was twenty-four, trying to keep us afloat after our father died. I turned my back for twenty minutes at the old rail yards down by the East River. Just twenty minutes."
The memory seemed to physically crush him. He planted one hand against the damp brick wall beside my head, leaning in close, his breath warm against my chilled cheek.
"When I turned back, she was gone," he whispered hoarsely. "The police searched for three days. They found her winter coat caught on a rusted iron piling near the shipping slips."
"When they found her coat," I echoed softly, a strange, terrifying ringing starting up in my ears, "there was blood on the sleeve..."
Dominic froze. His eyes widened with shock. "...and a Polaroid photograph tucked into the inside pocket," he finished for me, his voice trembling violently.
"The photograph," I whispered, the fragmented memories of my earliest, most terrifying childhood nightmares suddenly bubbling up from the dark corners of my mind, "showed that exact symbol... burned into her shoulder."
Dominic sucked in a sharp breath. "How do you know that? The police never released the details of the photo to the press. It was kept confidential in the active homicide files!"
"Because I was wearing it," I choked out, tears finally breaking over my lower lashes, burning hot tracks down my dirt-stained cheeks. "I didn't know where I got the scar. The social workers told me I fell against a radiator when I was little. But I always knew they were lying. I remember the smell of sulfur. I remember a man holding a metal stamp over an open flame. I remember screaming until my throat bled."
May you like
Dominic pulled back slowly, his hand dropping from the wall. He stared at me not as a captive, not as a thief who had stolen Rourke’s ledger, but as a miracle he had stopped praying for over a decade ago.
"You're alive," he whispered, a tremor breaking his stoic facade. "My little sister... is alive."
