Chapter 37 - The Lost Sister

The dining room went completely still when Graham walked back inside, holding the open silver locket in his palm. He set it gently on the center of the oak table between Arthur and Elaine.
Arthur picked it up, holding it close to the chandelier light. "May fourth, nineteen ninety-one. Kalamazoo."
Elaine covered her mouth, her eyes widening. "A sister? Graham, did your mother have another child after you and Julian were put in foster care?"
"No," Graham said, his voice low, gravelly with shock. "My mother died in nineteen eighty-nine. If this child was born in ninety-one... she had to have been born to our father."
Arthur looked up sharply. "You told me you never knew your father."
"We didn't," Graham said. "He abandoned my mother in Detroit before Julian and I were two years old. We didn't even have a name for him on our birth certificates—just 'Father Unknown.' My mother took her maiden name, Miller, and moved us to Kalamazoo to clean hotel rooms."
Mara pulled her laptop onto the table, opening the Michigan vital records portal. "If she was born in Kalamazoo in ninety-one, there has to be a birth registration. But if she was born to an unknown father, she might have been surrendered through safe haven or private adoption."
"Julian knew about her," Julianne said, stepping into the room. "He told me once, years ago, when he had a couple of beers after a long shift. He said that right before he aged out of the foster home in South Bend, an older social worker came to see him. She told him that his father had resurfaced in Kalamazoo in ninety, fathered another child with a local woman, and then vanished again when the girl was three years old. The state placed the girl in an adoption track."
Arthur stood up from his chair, his hands resting heavily on the table. "An Ellison doesn't leave family behind. We didn't leave you behind, Graham, and we aren't leaving your little sister out in the cold."
Graham looked at the old man, his chest swelling with profound emotion. "Arthur, she could be anywhere in the country. She could have an adopted name, an adopted life, a family that loves her."
May you like
"And she could be wondering why her brothers never came looking for her," Arthur replied, his voice ringing with absolute certainty. "Just like you sat on that bus for thirty years wondering if we hated you. We find her, Graham. Even if it takes every private investigator between Detroit and Chicago."
Mara smiled, her fingers already dancing across the keyboard. "I’m already running cross-references on Kalamazoo adoptions from May ninety-one. Give me twenty-four hours."