Chapter 2
Dr. Walsh took Eli into a consultation room while Tessa remained beside Naomi’s door. The room contained a round table, four plastic chairs, and a whiteboard still covered with fragments of another family’s crisis plan. Eli sat but could not keep his knees still. Through the wall came the muffled sound of Naomi crying for Jonah.
“Is Naomi’s mother alive?” Dr. Walsh asked.
Eli covered his face. “Yes.”
The single word altered the room. Tessa stopped writing. Dr. Walsh leaned forward, her voice losing none of its calm. “Start at the beginning, and do not decide for us which details matter.”
Eli explained that Naomi had grown up believing her mother, Evelyn Harrow, died at Riverside Bridge when Naomi was six. There had never been a funeral because Evelyn’s body had supposedly been swept downstream. Naomi’s father, Samuel Harrow, said there was nothing to bury. He raised Naomi alone and refused to discuss the night Evelyn disappeared.
Seven months into Naomi’s pregnancy, Eli received a certified letter at his construction office. Evelyn had included a copy of her driver’s license, Naomi’s birth certificate, and a photograph of herself holding Naomi as a baby. She asked for nothing except the chance to speak with her daughter before Jonah was born.
“You met her?” Tessa asked.
Eli nodded without looking up. “Once. At a diner outside Millhaven.”
“And you concluded she was really Evelyn?”
“She knew things no stranger could know. Naomi’s first word. The scar behind her left ear. The yellow rain boots she wore the night of the bridge.”
“Why didn’t you tell your wife?”
“Samuel said Evelyn was dangerous. He showed me old psychiatric records and said she had tried to jump with Naomi in her arms. Naomi was eight months pregnant. She was barely sleeping even then. He convinced me that the shock could hurt her or the baby.”
Dr. Walsh’s expression hardened. “Did either of you tell Naomi’s obstetrician that her mother had a serious psychiatric history connected to childbirth?”
Eli stared at her.
“That information could have changed Naomi’s postpartum care,” she said. “It could have led to preventive treatment, sleep protection, and closer monitoring.”
“I didn’t know it worked like that.”
“You did know enough to conceal a living parent from your wife.”
The door opened, and a nurse quietly told Dr. Walsh that Naomi had agreed to take medication only after Tessa promised to remain where she could see her. Jonah was being monitored in the pediatric unit, and a nurse had photographed every identification band, sensor, and injection site so Naomi could examine them later. Dr. Walsh thanked her and waited until the door closed.
“Two truths can exist at the same time,” she told Eli. “Your wife may be experiencing postpartum psychosis, and people she trusted may have lied to her. Treating the illness does not require us to participate in the lie.”
Tessa asked whether Evelyn had contacted Naomi directly. Eli said he had blocked the first number Evelyn used, then immediately corrected himself. “Samuel told me to. He said if she reached Naomi without warning, she might destabilize her.”
“Did she try another number?”
“I don’t know.”
Tessa remembered the coat Naomi had been wearing on the bridge. Her phone had been sealed in an evidence bag after the rescue. She retrieved it from the nurses’ station, obtained Eli’s permission to unlock it, and found seventeen missed calls from the night before. Most were from Eli. One had come from a blocked number at 1:48 a.m. A voicemail remained unheard.
Naomi’s scream came through the wall before Tessa could press play. A nurse rushed past the window. Naomi had awakened enough to realize Jonah was no longer in the room, and panic had returned with brutal speed. Tessa went inside alone.
Naomi stood in the corner, gripping the collar of a hospital robe. “They moved him.”
“He is upstairs with a pediatric nurse. He is warm, and no one has found anything inside him.”
“They won’t find it because it dissolves.”
“I heard what you said about your mother.” Tessa lowered herself into the nearest chair. “Eli confirmed that she is alive.”
Naomi’s fingers loosened around the robe.
For the first time since the bridge, the terror on her face gave way to something sharper. “You believe me?”
“I believe that your mother is alive. I also believe your mind is frightening you in ways that could hurt you and Jonah. We are going to take both things seriously.”
Naomi sat on the edge of the bed. She looked suddenly young, like someone who had been punished for telling the truth and no longer knew what truth was worth. “He told me she drowned. Every year, he took me to that bridge and made me leave flowers.”
“Your father?”
Naomi nodded. “Eli knew?”
“Yes.”
Her face collapsed. Tessa stayed while she wept, neither touching her nor offering a promise she could not guarantee. When the medication began pulling Naomi toward sleep, she whispered, “My phone. She called my phone.”
After Naomi slept, Tessa returned to the consultation room. Eli was standing by the window when she played the voicemail. Static came first, followed by a woman’s uneven breath.
“Naomi, my name is Evelyn Harrow. I am your mother. I know what Samuel told you, and I know Eli has been afraid to tell you the truth. What happened at Riverside Bridge was not what you were told. Please don’t go there alone. Call me when you’re safe.”
A truck passed in the background of the recording. Then Evelyn added one final sentence.
“Eli knows where to find me.”
Eli sank into his chair.
Dr. Walsh stopped the message. “Your wife did not imagine that call.”
“No,” Eli whispered.
Tessa looked through the glass at Naomi sleeping beneath a hospital blanket. Her wrists were bruised from the rescue. Even in sleep, one hand remained curled against her chest as if Jonah were still there.
“What Naomi heard afterward may have been shaped by her illness,” Dr. Walsh said. “But someone handed that illness a terrible truth and left her alone with it.”
May you like
The emergency-department doors opened at the end of the corridor. An older man in a charcoal overcoat entered and spoke briefly to security. Eli saw him first.
Samuel Harrow had arrived.
