solutions

Chapter 3

I didn’t turn my phone back on for three days.

I spent the time fixing things around the lake house. Hammered a loose board on the dock. Pulled weeds from the flower beds my mom had planted thirty years ago. Scrubbed the kitchen counters until they shone.

Work kept my hands busy. Kept my mind from wandering.

But every night, when the sun went down, I thought about that first day Vanessa came to my house.

It was three years ago, a rainy Saturday in March. Daniel had called that morning, giddy.

Mom, I’m bringing someone over. Her name is Vanessa. She’s amazing. You’re gonna love her.

I’d spent all morning cooking. Baked his favorite lemon cake, made meatloaf, set the table with my good china. I was so nervous my hands shook when I lit the candles.

They’d arrived an hour late. Vanessa didn’t apologize. She walked in, looked around my small living room, and smiled that same sharp smile she’d worn at the wedding.

Cute place, she’d said. So… cozy.

She’d barely touched her dinner. Pushed the meatloaf around her plate with a fork, made small comments about how hard it must be to keep up a house alone, how she’d never be able to live somewhere so far from the city.

Daniel had laughed it off. She’s just honest, he’d told me later when she was in the bathroom. That’s why I love her.

I’d wanted to believe him.

I’d ignored every red flag after that.

The time she’d “accidentally” thrown away the photo of my mom I’d left on Daniel’s apartment mantel. The time she’d told Daniel I’d called her lazy, when I’d only asked if she was planning to go back to work after she quit her job six months into dating him. The holidays she’d insisted they spend with her family, every single one, even though it was just me alone at my house.

Each time, Daniel had taken her side.

Mom, you’re being too sensitive.

She didn’t mean it like that.

Can’t you just try to get along for me?

I’d tried. God, I’d tried. I’d bought her birthday gifts that cost more than my weekly grocery bill. I’d taken her out for fancy lunches, listened to her complain about her job, her friends, her family. I’d bitten my tongue until it bleed, all because I wanted Daniel to be happy.

And what had it gotten me?

A seat next to the trash.

On the fourth morning, I was sitting on the porch drinking coffee when a car pulled up the gravel drive.

It wasn’t Daniel’s sedan.

It was a beat-up blue pickup I knew well.

Tyler. Daniel’s best friend since third grade. The boy who’d lived two doors down from us in Charleston, who’d eaten more meals at my table than I could count.

He got out, holding a paper bag, and walked up the steps.

“Hey, Margaret,” he said, his voice soft.

“Hey, honey,” I said, standing up. “What are you doing all the way up here?”

He held up the bag. “Brought you those pecan danishes you like. From the bakery on King Street.”

I felt my throat tighten. No one had brought me anything since the wedding. No one had even called, except Daniel and Vanessa.

I let him in, poured him a cup of coffee, and we sat at the kitchen table.

He didn’t speak for a long time. Just twisted his coffee mug around in his hands.

“I was there, you know,” he said finally. “At the wedding. When it happened.”

I nodded. I’d seen him in the back of the church, giving me a small wave.

“I saw Vanessa put your card on that chair,” he said. “I heard what she said to you.”

My breath caught.

“I wanted to say something,” he said, looking down at the table. “I should have. But Daniel was my best man, and I… I froze. I’m sorry.”

“It’s not your fault,” I said quietly.

He looked up at me. His eyes were angry. “She planned it, Margaret. The whole thing.”

I leaned forward. “What do you mean?”

“I was standing by the bridal suite before the ceremony,” he said. “Vanessa was in there with her sister and her bridesmaids. They were laughing. She said she’d told the wedding planner to put your seat outside on purpose. Said it was the only way to ‘break’ you, to make you so mad you’d cause a scene, so Daniel would finally choose her over you for good.”

My hands went cold.

“And the lake house?” I whispered.

Tyler nodded. “She talked about that too. Said once the deed was in their name, she’d convince Daniel to sell it, buy a bigger house downtown, and make sure you never came around. Said you were a leech, that you’d been holding Daniel back his whole life.”

I closed my eyes.

It was worse than I’d thought.

She hadn’t just disliked me. She’d targeted me. Targeted Daniel. All for a house.

“Does Daniel know?” I said.

Tyler shook his head. “I tried to tell him yesterday. At the brunch the day after the wedding. He wouldn’t listen. Said I was lying, that I’d always hated Vanessa. He almost punched me.”

He reached into his pocket and pulled out his phone.

“I recorded it,” he said. “The conversation in the bridal suite. I didn’t mean to, my phone was still recording from the best man speech I was practicing. But it’s all there. Every word.”

He slid the phone across the table to me.

The play button glowed on the screen.

I stared at it for a long time.

This was the proof I’d need if Daniel really did take me to court. This was the truth, laid bare.

But it was also the end of everything Daniel thought he knew about the woman he’d married.

I pressed play.

May you like

Vanessa’s voice filled the small kitchen, bright and cruel.

By tonight, that lake house is mine. And once it is, Margaret Hale is gone from our lives forever.

Related Stories

Other posts