Chapter 4 - The Interrogation and the House of Cards
By 9:00 PM, the atmosphere inside the Covington police precinct felt heavy with fluorescent light and bureaucratic precision. Lucas was sitting in a sterile holding cell three corridors down, his arrogant bravado completely shattered, weeping into his hands as a public defender was paged.
Meanwhile, my mother and father had been summoned down to the station by Detective Vance—a sharp, no-nonsense investigator who specialized in white-collar and domestic property fraud.
They sat side-by-side in the hard plastic chairs of the consultation room, looking defensive, indignant, and profoundly out of touch with reality. My mother was dabbing nervously at her eyes with a crumpled tissue, while Dad sat with his arms crossed tightly over his chest, glaring at me as if I were the one who had committed a crime.
"I don't know what kind of ungrateful witch raises a daughter like this," Dad snapped the moment Detective Vance walked into the room carrying a thick file folder. "We are her parents! We needed help for our son, and she called the police like a common criminal!"
Detective Vance didn't even blink. She tossed a certified copy of the vehicle title, bank records, and the audio transcript of Dad’s phone call onto the stainless-steel table.
"Mr. Santana," Detective Vance said, her voice dropping into a dangerous, measured register. "Let’s get a few basic facts straight so we are operating in reality. Your daughter owns this vehicle outright. She paid for every cent of it. You took a spare key under false pretenses of an emergency, removed her property without permission, and handed it to an unlicensed driver."
"It’s a family arrangement!" Mother chimed in, her voice trembling. "In our family, we share! Lucas has a baby on the way! Elina has no one depending on her! Why shouldn't she sacrifice a little bit for her brother?"
"Because," Detective Vance interrupted sharply, opening the file to reveal the notarized gift form, "sharing does not include committing felony forgery. Mr. Santana admitted—on a recorded line witnessed by three officers—that he forged his daughter’s signature on a state title transfer document."
Dad scoffed, waving his hand dismissively. "Oh, please. It’s just a signature. Fathers sign things for their kids all the time. It’s a family matter. The prosecutor will throw this out immediately."
Detective Vance leaned forward, resting her palms on the table. "Mr. Santana, forgery of a legal title instrument and interstate motor vehicle theft are class-level felonies in the Commonwealth of Kentucky. Combined with aiding and abetting an unlicensed driver, you are looking at up to ten years in a state correctional facility. And your son? Because he was actively driving a stolen vehicle with fraudulent paperwork while fully aware his license was suspended, his probation for his previous DUI is officially revoked. He’s looking at hard time."
The air in the room went completely dead.
Mother let out a sharp, choked gasp, dropping her tissue onto the floor. "Ten years? Prison? Over a car?"
"Over grand theft, forgery, and systematic abuse of trust," Detective Vance corrected coldly. She looked directly at me. "Elina, do you wish to press full criminal charges, or is there any statement you’d like to make before we formally book them?"
Dad’s arrogant posture finally crumbled. He looked across the table at me, his eyes wide with sudden, desperate terror. The golden-boy armor had vanished, leaving behind an aging man who realized his lifelong favoritism had finally hit a brick wall of absolute accountability.
"Elina..." Dad’s voice cracked, sounding small and broken for the first time in my life. "Please. Don't do this to your family. We're your blood."
I looked at him—really looked at him—for a long, quiet moment. I saw thirty years of being the invisible shock absorber for my brother’s failures, thirty years of being told my needs didn't matter, thirty years of emotional extortion wrapped up in the word family.
May you like
"You stopped acting like my family a long time ago, Dad," I said quietly.
I turned to Detective Vance. "Press every single charge. Let the courts decide how much family helps family."
