Chapter 2 - The Fire in the Night

The rest of the morning passed in a whirlwind of frantic phone calls and trembling hands. Tessa Morgan had worked at Belmont Auctions long enough to know how the machinery of the high-end art world operated. She wasn't just an appraiser; she held a doctorate in art conservation from Columbia University.
“They’re terrified, Carol,” Tessa said, pacing the worn linoleum floor while Sophie brought her a mug of black coffee. “If Samuel painted that landscape, he painted the other five Arthur Fontaine canvases that have surfaced over the last thirty years. That’s nearly eighty million dollars in fraudulent sales through Mercer’s trust alone. It’s forgery, wire fraud, and grand larceny.”
“Can they take this house?” Sophie whispered, hugging her grandmother’s waist.
“No, sweetheart,” Carol said, smoothing Sophie’s brown hair. “They’re trying to scare us because they’re guilty.”
Tessa laid Samuel’s notebook on the table. “We need to move this evidence immediately. We can’t keep it here. I have a secure climate-controlled lab at the university annex in Lexington. If we run infrared reflectography and pigment spectroscopy on Samuel’s original sketches, we can build a baseline chemical fingerprint.”
“What about the portrait?” Carol asked.
She led Tessa down the narrow hallway to the back bedroom. In the corner, beneath an antique quilt, hung the painting Samuel had refused to sell. It was small—barely eighteen by twenty-four inches—framed in rough pine Samuel had planed himself.
The painting depicted Carol at twenty-one, standing ankle-deep in the shallow river with a woven wicker basket balanced on her hip. Sunlight sparkled off the water like shards of shattered glass. Her hair was windblown, her cheeks flushed with youth, and in the bottom right corner, partially obscured by wild water lilies, was a tiny hand-painted silver bell, followed by the initials S.B.
Tessa stared at the canvas, tears springing to her eyes. “It’s breathtaking, Carol. The brushwork, the impasto technique on the water... it’s identical to the Fontaine landscape at Belmont. Exactly identical.”
“He painted it for our first anniversary,” Carol said softly. “He said as long as I kept it, he’d always be standing on the riverbank watching over me.”
By afternoon, Tessa had packed the journals, receipts, and Samuel’s old brushes into padded lockboxes, loading them into the trunk of her compact car. Carol refused to leave the portrait. “I’m taking Sophie to my sister’s trailer in Harlan County tonight,” Carol decided. “We’ll meet you in Lexington tomorrow morning.”
Night fell over Bell Creek with an eerie, unnatural quiet. The crickets had stopped chirping. Sophie was already asleep in the back room with her duffel bag packed by the door. Carol sat in the rocker by the front window, keeping watch, an old 20-gauge shotgun resting across her knees.
At 2:15 AM, the smell of burning gasoline cut through the crisp night air.
Carol stood abruptly. Outside, flames were already licking the dry wood of the back porch. Two figures dressed in black hoodies were sprinting toward an idling SUV parked down the lane.
“Sophie! Wake up! Fire!” Carol screamed, dropping the gun and rushing down the hallway.
Smoke was already filling the low ceiling with thick, blinding gray clouds. Sophie coughed violently, tumbling out of bed into her grandmother’s arms. The back door was a sheet of roaring orange fire.
“The front door, baby! Run!” Carol shouted.
Carol grabbed the anniversary portrait off the wall with one hand, wrapping her woolen shawl around it, and shoved Sophie out through the front screen door. They stumbled into the cool night grass just as the living room windows shattered from the heat, showering glass onto the porch.
Neighbors came running in their bathrobes with garden hoses and buckets, but the dry timbers of the old house went up like tinder. Within twenty minutes, the roof collapsed in a shower of sparks.
May you like
Sitting on the damp grass with soot on her cheeks, clutching the wrapped portrait to her chest while Sophie sobbed in her lap, Carol looked up at the burning embers rising into the Kentucky sky.
They thought they had destroyed her memories. They thought they had burned the truth to ash. But as she felt the solid wood frame of the portrait beneath her trembling fingers, a cold, unyielding resolve settled deep into her bones. Andrew Mercer had made this personal.