Chapter 4 - The Black Book of Scott Mercer

Carol stood up slowly, positioning herself squarely between Andrew Mercer and the examination table where her husband’s painting lay.
“You’re trespassing, Mr. Mercer,” Tessa Morgan said, stepping forward with her clipboard pressed against her chest like a shield. “This is a state university research facility operating under a formal court preservation order issued this morning by the Fayette County district attorney.”
Mercer ignored Tessa completely. His gaze settled on Carol, his lip curling with cold contempt. “You’re playing a very dangerous game, Mrs. Bennett. Arson is a tragic crime, but trying to pin your hometown misfortune on my family’s name will cost you whatever little you have left.”
“I didn't need to pin it on you,” Carol said steadily. “Your father did that forty years ago.”
Mercer let out a dry, dismissive chuckle. “My father was a visionary patron of the arts. He discovered talent across the globe. He certainly didn't waste his time stealing scraps from Kentucky hillbillies.”
“He didn't discover them,” Carol replied. “He hunted them.”
From beneath the table, Tessa pulled out the heavy, fire-resistant lockbox that had survived the night in her car’s trunk. She unlocked the brass latch with a sharp click and lifted out Samuel’s notebook. But beneath Samuel’s journal was another book—one that Tessa had uncovered inside Samuel’s old trunk the previous evening.
It was a small, black leather-bound ledger embossed with gold initials: S.M.
Scott Mercer.
Andrew Mercer’s eyes widened for a fraction of a second, his smug composure faltering. “Where did you get that?”
“Your father left it on our kitchen table the last day he visited in the fall of 1979,” Carol said. “He was in such a hurry to load twelve canvases into his Cadillac that he forgot it beside the kerosene lamp. Samuel kept it, hoping Scott would come back for it so he could ask for his paintings back.”
Tessa flipped the yellowed pages of the black ledger. “This isn't an art dealer’s ledger, Mr. Mercer. It’s an inventory of theft. Page after page lists struggling, impoverished painters from the Rust Belt, the Ozarks, and the Appalachian hollows. Your father bought their works for twenty, thirty, fifty dollars apiece, promising to exhibit them in New York. Then he shipped them to an underground studio in Montreal to be scrubbed, overpainted, and relabeled under the names of obscure, deceased European masters.”
“That is absurd fiction!” Mercer hissed, his face reddening.
“It has your father’s handwriting, his corporate tax ID from 1978, and the exact canvas accession numbers matching the Mercer Trust collection,” Tessa countered. “Including Lot 402—the landscape sitting right here on this table. Scott Mercer paid Samuel Bennett forty dollars for it on October 14, 1974. And you were about to sell it for twelve million.”
Mercer took a step forward, his jaw tight, his hands clenching into fists. “You will never get this into a courtroom. I own half the judges in this state. I will have this entire department defunded by tomorrow morning!”
“You’re too late, Andrew,” a deep voice announced from the laboratory doorway.
May you like
Detective Marcus Vance—no relation to the Mercer lawyer, but the lead arson investigator from the Kentucky State Police—walked in, accompanied by four state troopers.
“Mr. Mercer,” the detective said, flashing his gold badge. “We pulled security footage from the gas station outside Bell Creek from last night. The men who set fire to Mrs. Bennett’s home were driving an Escalade registered to Mercer Asset Management. You have the right to remain silent.”