Chapter 4 - The Coffee Shop Confrontation

I didn't go to Elodie's apartment, and I didn't send Reid. If she was playing a game of leverage, walking into her private space would give her the home-turf advantage. Instead, I sent her a simple text message at three o'clock: Elodie, I'm at the Black Oak Coffeehouse on Fourth Street. I'd love to chat more about the rolls recipe you asked about at dinner.
It was petty bait, but she bit instantly. On my way, Mara! Can't wait!
The coffeehouse was warm, smelling of roasted beans, steamed oat milk, and cinnamon scones. I picked a small corner booth secluded behind a large potted fiddle-leaf fig. On the wood table, I set a recording app running on my phone, screen facedown, partially hidden under a paper napkin. Beside it, I placed an envelope containing two items: a high-resolution printout of Mom wearing the locket in 1995, and a copy of the state penal code regarding the unauthorized removal of property from a deceased individual.
Ten minutes later, the door chimed. Elodie walked in, looking effortlessly chic in a houndstooth trench coat and ankle boots. Beneath the unbuttoned collar of her coat, the gold oval gleamed against her dark turtleneck sweater. She spotted me and smiled that bright, toothy smile that had turned my stomach on Thursday.
""Mara! It is so good to see you again,"" she chirped, sliding into the leather booth across from me. ""I was telling Reid just yesterday how much I loved your house. It has so much... history.""
""It does,"" I replied evenly, not offering a smile in return. ""A lot of history. That's actually why I asked you here, Elodie.""
Her smile faltered slightly, the sharp intelligence behind her eyes focusing instantly. ""Oh? Not the rolls?""
""No,"" I said, reaching out and sliding the Christmas photograph across the table. ""I wanted to talk about your necklace.""
Elodie looked down at the photograph. Her eyes traced the silver-soldered link resting on my mother’s collarbone in the picture, then dropped to her own chest. Her posture stiffened. The sweet, bubbly persona she had worn at Thanksgiving melted away like frost on hot iron, replaced by a cool, unblinking glare.
""I see,"" she said quietly. She didn't flinch. She didn't act surprised. She simply crossed her legs under the table and rested her manicured hands on the wood. ""Reid talked to you.""
""Reid didn't have to,"" I lied smoothly. ""I went to Baird & Sons this morning. I pulled the intake and release forms. Lawrence Baird has already filed an internal report regarding an unauthorized removal of personal property.""
Elodie let out a soft, amused scoff and picked up her ceramic mug of water. ""Mara, let's not play games. Your brother is an idiot. He's a charming, spineless idiot who drowns in debt and looks for anyone to bail him out. He stole this necklace off your mother's corpse because he thought it was worth thousands. When he realized it was worthless junk metal, he was too cowardly to put it back.""
Hearing her say the words out loud—so casually, so brutally—made my blood boil. ""And what does that make you, Elodie? A woman who wears stolen jewelry from a dead stranger?""
""It makes me someone who protects her investments,"" she whispered, leaning across the table, her eyes narrowing. ""Reid owes twelve thousand dollars to my cousin's auto-repair business for parts he ordered under the table. That debt was signed over to me. This little trinket is my collateral. He doesn't get it back, and you don't get it back, until that balance is paid in full.""
May you like
""That is extortion,"" I hissed. ""And possession of stolen goods. I can call Detective Miller right now. He was Mom's neighbor for twenty years.""
Elodie smiled, leaning back against the booth cushion. ""Go ahead, Mara. Call him. Let's see what happens to your precious baby brother. If the police get involved, I won't just hand over the necklace—I'll hand over the text messages from Reid begging me to pawn it for him. I'll make sure he gets charged with grand larceny and desecration of a corpse. He'll lose his dealer's license, his job, and he'll spend two years in state prison. Are you really willing to destroy Reid's entire life just to put a cheap piece of gold in a drawer?""