Chapter 5 - The Trap Snaps Shut

The silence that stretched between us was suffocating. Elodie sat with absolute confidence, radiating the smug certainty of someone who believed she held every card in the deck. She took a slow sip from her cup, watching me through hooded eyes, waiting for me to break, cry, or offer a check.
""Twelve thousand dollars,"" I said, keeping my voice dangerously flat.
""Twelve thousand. Cash or cashier's check,"" she replied smoothly, reaching up with two fingers to stroke the polished face of the locket. ""Once the funds clear, the necklace goes in an envelope and onto your doorstep. If not, maybe I'll melt it down. Or maybe I'll wear it to your family's Christmas gathering. I hear Aunt Bethany throws a lovely party.""
My jaw tightened until my teeth ached. She wasn't just a parasite; she was thoroughly sadistic. She was enjoying every second of degrading our grief.
""You really think you're untouchable, don't you?"" I asked softly.
""I'm practical, Mara,"" she countered, checking her watch with an air of theatrical boredom. ""I don't let sentimentality get in the way of business. Reid made a mess. I'm just collecting what's owed. You have forty-eight hours to decide whether your brother wears an orange jumpsuit or stays on the showroom floor.""
She started to slide out of the booth, gathering her designer purse.
""Before you go, Elodie,"" I said, reaching down and turning my phone over on the table.
The red recording bar was glowing brightly, pulsing with every ambient sound in the room. Beside it, the timer read: 07:42.
Elodie froze mid-rise, her coat half-fastened, her eyes darting from the screen to my face. ""What is that?""
""In this state,"" I said, leaning forward until our faces were only inches apart, ""audio recording requires the consent of only one party. I consented.""
Her face went from smug to sheet-white in a fraction of a second. ""You tricked me.""
""I asked you here to talk about a necklace. You sat down and openly confessed to extorting twelve thousand dollars from my family using stolen property as leverage. You admitted on tape that you knew the item was taken from a deceased person, which satisfies the statutory definition of knowing possession and trafficking in stolen goods.""
""You wouldn't use that,"" she stammered, her voice suddenly losing all its polished venom. ""It incriminates Reid! It proves he took it!""
""Reid has already signed a sworn confession at the county prosecutor's office,"" I lied with utter, terrifying calm. ""Thirty minutes ago. He accepted full accountability for petty theft under mitigating family circumstances. The prosecutor offered him diversion and probation because he cooperated. But you, Elodie? You don't get diversion for felony extortion and criminal blackmail.""
Her breath hitched. She looked around the coffee shop, suddenly realizing how loud her voice had been, realizing that two patrons at a neighboring table were staring at her. Her hands began to tremble.
""You're bluffing,"" she whispered, though her cracking voice betrayed her terror.
""Try me,"" I said, dialing a three-digit number on the keypad and holding the glowing screen up to her face. ""I hit call, and Detective Miller will meet you in the parking lot. You have thirty seconds to unhook that chain and place it on this table. If I have to stand up, you leave here in handcuffs.""
""You can't do this!"" she hissed.
""Twenty seconds, Elodie.""
Her eyes darted wildly toward the door, then back to my cold, steady stare. She saw no weakness, no hesitation, and no room for negotiation. She realized that I would happily watch the entire world burn before I let her walk out of that shop wearing Sylvie Whitcomb's locket.
With shaking, clumsy fingers, Elodie reached behind the nape of her neck. The clasp fought her, snagging in her hair, but she yanked it free with a sharp gasp of pain. She dropped the chain onto the wooden table between us.
It landed with a soft, metallic chime—the tiny silver link gleaming under the coffee shop’s pendant lights.
""Take it,"" she spat, her eyes venomous with humiliation. ""It’s worthless garbage anyway.""
May you like
""Leave,"" I said.
She grabbed her purse, knocked her chair sideways against the floor, and fled through the front doors into the winter chill, nearly colliding with a mother pushing a stroller on the sidewalk outside.