solutions

Chapter 53 - What Four Years Could Not Erase

Lucas chose a coffee shop with windows facing the street.

Anna had agreed to meet for thirty minutes. Claire would sit nearby, and Lucas understood that the meeting could end whenever Anna wanted.

He arrived early.

She hated noticing that.

He stood when she entered, then sat when she shook her head at the gesture.

“Don’t make this formal.”

“All right.”

She placed his note on the table.

“Why didn’t you answer my letters?”

Lucas looked at the paper.

“I handled them badly. I never sent a single answer.”

Anna stared at him.

“Badly?”

“I told myself you were better without me. It sounded noble when I was ashamed. Mostly it meant I didn’t have to hear what I’d done.”

Her eyes burned.

“Ben had colic. I walked him until my back hurt. Mom worked extra shifts. I stood in a pharmacy once and counted quarters while he cried.”

Lucas held very still.

“Don’t sit there looking sad,” she said. “Say something.”

“I’m sorry.”

She laughed, furious.

“I know how small that is,” he added. “I don’t have something larger that becomes true because I say it.”

That stopped her more effectively than a defense would have.

He told her about prison. About returning home and drinking again. About jobs lost, one terrible winter sleeping on a friend’s couch, and the morning he finally asked for help without deciding in advance how much help he deserved.

Four sober years did not mean four easy years.

He worked now for a carpentry contractor. He rented a room, paid old obligations through formal arrangements, and kept appointments with people who knew when he was lying to himself.

“Does that make you safe?” Anna asked.

“It makes me responsible for continuing. It doesn’t require you to trust me.”

Outside, a bus hissed to a stop.

Claire looked down at her book, giving the conversation privacy without abandoning Anna to it.

Lucas explained his father’s interest. His older brother, Christopher, had died two years earlier. Warren had begun talking about family succession and a grandson he had once refused to acknowledge.

“He asked me to arrange a visit,” Lucas said.

“So you came because he asked.”

“No. But he’s the reason I stopped pretending I could keep postponing this without consequences.”

Anna looked away.

“Convenient distinction.”

“I understand why it sounds that way.”

“Then don’t ask to see Ben.”

Lucas swallowed.

“All right.”

“You can answer questions. You can give my lawyer the information she asks for. You can stop making your father my problem.”

“Yes.”

She watched him for several seconds, searching for the old impatience, the charm that appeared whenever consequences became uncomfortable.

He only waited.

The thirty minutes ended.

Anna stood.

“Does he look like me?” Lucas asked before he could stop himself.

She looked down at him.

“Sometimes. Mostly he looks like a child who didn’t deserve to be left.”

Lucas bowed his head.

Anna walked outside before she cried.

Claire followed, holding the car keys without asking whether she had done well.

They walked slowly to the car without discussing what should happen next. A delivery bicycle passed, its bell startling Anna so badly she stepped toward Claire.

“I hate this,” she said.

“I know.”

“No. I hate that he looks tired. I hate noticing. I wanted not to care whether he ate breakfast.”

Claire stopped beside the passenger door.

“Caring doesn't make a decision for you.”

Anna looked down at her hands.

“I don't want Nathan thinking I'm about to forgive everything.”

“Then tell him what you want him to understand. He can listen.”

A woman hurried past carrying flowers wrapped in brown paper. For a moment, Anna envied the simplicity of having somewhere to take them. Then she opened the car door and let Claire drive, grateful not to explain every mile between anger and home.

In the car, Anna pressed her palms against her eyes.

“I wanted him to be awful.”

Claire waited.

“If he was awful, I could just close the door.”

“You can still choose the pace.”

May you like

Anna looked through the windshield at Lucas sitting alone beside the window.

For the first time, she understood that uncertainty could hurt almost as much as knowing.

Related Stories

Other posts