Chapter 54 - The Question Ben Asked Twice

Anna told Ben on a Sunday morning, after pancakes and before the day could become crowded with distractions.
They sat on the couch in the apartment above the florist.
“There’s someone who has asked to talk to me,” she said. “Your father.”
Ben stared at the dinosaur in his hands.
“My real father?”
“He is your father. The people who take care of you now are real, too.”
He turned the dinosaur over.
“Was he lost?”
Anna felt something tear quietly inside her.
“No. He made choices that kept him away.”
“Bad choices?”
“Yes.”
“Like stealing?”
She looked at him carefully.
“Some of them were. He also drank in ways that hurt him and other people. He has been working for a long time to change that.”
Ben considered the information with the grave concentration he usually gave complicated game rules.
“Do I have to see him?”
“Not today. We’re going to get help deciding how to handle this. You can ask questions.”
“Can I still see Uncle Nathan?”
Anna pulled him close before answering.
“Of course.”
He pressed against her for a moment, then sat back.
“What if Dad says no?”
The fear was so practical, so specific, that Anna had to breathe twice before she could speak.
“No one gets to erase the people who love you because someone else arrives.”
Ben nodded, not entirely convinced.
That afternoon, Nathan came to take him to the library. Anna had told her brother about the conversation, and he arrived carrying nothing except the books they needed to return.
In the car, Ben watched passing houses.
“Did Mom tell you?”
“Yes.”
“Are you mad?”
“At you? No.”
“At him?”
Nathan thought about Daniel, about the years anger had occupied rooms nobody else could use.
“I’m being careful. Your mom gets to decide what she needs. You get to say how you feel.”
Ben rubbed a finger along the edge of a library book.
“What if I want to see him?”
“Then you can tell her.”
“What if I don’t?”
“You can tell her that, too.”
At the library, Ben chose books about space instead of dinosaurs. Nathan treated this unexpected expansion of interests as a matter requiring professional advice.
A librarian helped them find a book about the moon.
Ben opened it to a picture of astronauts leaving footprints.
“Do those stay?”
“For a long time,” Nathan said, reading the caption.
Ben touched the photograph.
On the drive back, he asked the question again.
“Can I still see you?”
Nathan pulled into a parking space outside the florist and turned toward him.
“Yes.”
“Even if I like him?”
Nathan felt his throat close.
“Especially if you like him. You don’t have to protect my feelings by making yours smaller.”
Ben studied his face, then nodded.
Upstairs, Anna listened while her son explained the moon. He did not mention his father until bedtime.
“Maybe I want to ask him a question.”
“All right,” she said. “We’ll work out a way that feels safe.”
At bedtime, he brought out the moon book again.
“Can you read the footprint part?”
Anna sat beside him and found the page. He listened with his head against her arm, interrupting to ask whether astronauts ever missed their mothers.
“Probably.”
“Even grown astronauts?”
“Especially those.”
He considered that, then asked for the page once more.
She read it without hurrying. For years, she had thought protecting him meant keeping every frightening detail outside the room. Now she wondered whether safety also meant letting a question enter and remain a question until they had time to understand it.
When he fell asleep, she left the book open on the chair. There were dishes waiting, tomorrow's orders to calculate, and a message she was not ready to answer. She took ten quiet minutes before touching any of them. For once, the waiting could belong to her.
After he fell asleep, she called Claire.
“I thought the hard part would be deciding whether to let him in.”
“What is it?”
May you like
“Realizing Ben has a door of his own.”
Claire sat quietly at the other end of the line, understanding how much courage it took not to stand in front of it.