Chapter 10 - The Audition

Benjamin practiced his song in the garage because he said the kitchen made him feel watched.
He had chosen an old folk tune Andrew used to sing while washing dishes. The melody was simple, but Benjamin kept stopping before the last verse. Each time, he frowned at the page as though the right notes might appear if he stared hard enough.
“You know you don’t have to do this,” I told him.
“I know.” He adjusted the paper on the music stand. “I want to.”
That was different. I had spent months trying to protect my children from choices they weren’t ready to make. I was learning that protection sometimes meant standing nearby while they made one.
The spring musical audition was scheduled for Saturday morning at the middle school. Benjamin wanted me to sit in the back. He also wanted me not to bring Amelia, Rosa, or a camera.
“Just you,” he said.
“Just me,” I promised.
Caroline was offended that she hadn’t been invited, but she recovered by volunteering to help the twins make signs. Lucy drew a star on the first one, then covered the whole page in glitter glue. Sophie ate a corner.
On Saturday, Benjamin walked into the auditorium carrying his sheet music in both hands. I chose a seat near the rear exit, exactly where he had asked.
The music teacher, Mr. Harlan, looked over the list. When he called Benjamin’s name, my son stood too quickly and nearly dropped his paper.
He glanced at me.
I gave him a small nod.
The first verse was steady. His voice sounded younger than it did when he argued with his brothers, and that nearly made me cry. Then came the pause before the last verse.
Benjamin’s mouth tightened.
A few students shifted in their chairs.
He lowered the page.
“Sorry,” he said. “I need a second.”
Mr. Harlan set down his pencil. “Take one.”
Benjamin breathed in. I knew the habit. He had learned it watching me prepare people to move through a crisis: pause, look, decide. He began again, this time without the sheet.
When he finished, the room stayed quiet for a heartbeat.
Then someone clapped.
Benjamin blinked, startled. Mr. Harlan smiled and wrote something on the clipboard. My son returned to his seat with his shoulders lifted.
Outside the auditorium, a woman in a gray coat waited beside the office. She was around fifty, with a red scarf folded neatly at her throat.
“Colonel Callahan?” she asked.
I moved closer to Benjamin. “Who are you?”
“My name is Mara Ellis. I knew Andrew through the Callahan Foundation.”
I had never heard of the Callahan Foundation.
Mara saw my expression. “It wasn’t a charity, exactly. Andrew started a small scholarship project with two other people. It helped children from military families with music lessons and school programs.”
“That sounds like something he would do,” I said.
“He never wanted his father involved.” She glanced toward the auditorium. “I’m sorry. I didn’t know how to reach you until I saw the school’s announcement.”
My first instinct was to ask why she had come to a school event. My second was to ask why Andrew had never told me about the project. Both questions seemed too large for the hallway.
Mara handed me a plain envelope. “He asked me to give you this if anything happened to him.”
The words struck hard.
“What did he mean by anything?”
“He didn’t explain. He only said that if Patrick ever tried to control the house or the children’s money, I should give this to you.”
Benjamin watched us from the auditorium doors.
I did not open the envelope there. I put it inside my coat and thanked her. Mara promised she would call Dana before discussing anything else.
That evening, after the children were asleep, I opened the envelope at the kitchen table. Inside was a handwritten note and a small brass key.
The note read:
Cynthia, this opens the cabinet in the old music room. I should have told you about the foundation sooner. I didn’t because I wanted to keep one thing from becoming a family argument.
I’m sorry.
The key fit the small cabinet beneath the built-in shelves. Andrew’s old sheet music was inside, along with a black notebook. I opened it and found pages of figures, names, and short entries in Andrew’s handwriting.
The last line was dated three days before the accident:
M.E. says the account is still active. Patrick’s been asking questions.
I set the notebook down.
May you like
From upstairs, Benjamin called in his sleep. The house was quiet around me, but the words on the page had opened another door.
And I had no idea what was waiting behind it.