solutions

Chapter 15 - The Garden Plans

Eleanor came to Dana’s office two days later with a cardboard tube and a box of old papers.

She had kept the garden plans because Evelyn had drawn them herself. The sketches showed a path winding past the rose beds and ending near the old oak tree. Evelyn had annotated every planting choice in blue ink.

“They were going to redo the garden,” Eleanor said. “Andrew thought the kids might like to help.”

The plan had been drawn years before the sale of the house. At the bottom, Evelyn had written a note to Andrew:

The house matters because people live in it. If your father ever makes the building more important than the family, choose the family.

I read it twice.

There was no legal instruction in the note. It was a private reminder from a grandmother to her grandson.

Eleanor found a second envelope tucked inside the tube. It held a photocopy of a letter Evelyn had written to her attorney. In it, Evelyn explained that she intended to sell the property to me because Patrick had become unable to maintain it and the creditors were closing in. She wanted me and Andrew to raise the children there, but she had made no promise that Patrick would inherit it.

Dana placed the letter in a protective sleeve.

“This may help with the family history,” she said. “The court has already ruled on title. This letter is still useful if someone repeats the claim that Evelyn intended the house to pass to Patrick.”

Eleanor seemed uneasy. “Margaret always said Evelyn promised it to the family.”

“She may have believed that,” I said.

“Or wanted us to believe it.”

Neither of us answered.

At home, I unrolled the garden plans on the kitchen table. The children crowded around.

“Can we plant something?” Caroline asked.

“There are still beds in the yard.”

“Can we make them Dad’s garden?”

I looked at Andrew’s name in Evelyn’s note. I could already picture the children digging in the soil, arguing over which flowers belonged where.

“We can plant one bed together,” I said.

The twins wanted tomatoes. Lucy wanted sunflowers. Benjamin suggested herbs because we actually used them. Caroline wanted roses like Evelyn’s.

“Can we do all of it?” Lucy asked.

“Probably not in one bed.”

“Then we need more beds.”

We spent the afternoon making a plan.

The garden project gave the children something to anticipate, but it also stirred questions. Caroline asked whether Evelyn had liked her. Jack wanted to know why the adults had argued so much over the house. Henry asked if the people in the old photographs were “the good side of the family.”

“There aren’t sides,” I said. “There are choices people make. Some are kind. Some are harmful. You get to decide who earns your trust.”

Benjamin looked up from the drawing. “Does Grandma earn it?”

“That’s a bigger decision than a garden plan.”

He accepted that.

The following Saturday, Eleanor came to help us identify the old rose varieties. She arrived carrying a tin of cookies and a folded letter.

“This one isn’t from Evelyn,” she said. “It’s from Andrew. He mailed it to me four months before he died.”

“Why didn’t you bring it with the others?”

“I thought it was personal.” She paused. “Then I read it again and realized it might matter.”

The letter contained a short description of the foundation’s finances, then a warning: Patrick had asked Andrew to sign a document promising future control over the Callahan Foundation. Andrew had refused. He believed his father wanted to use the scholarship project to make the family look charitable while diverting funds from the board.

I felt the room grow smaller.

“Did Andrew have proof?” I asked.

Eleanor shook her head. “He said he was looking for it.”

Dana read the letter later that day and called Mara Ellis.

Mara said the foundation had never been under Patrick’s control. But she also remembered a meeting where Patrick had insisted that Andrew sign an updated donor agreement.

“What happened to the agreement?” Dana asked.

Mara said she had taken it home to review. She never returned the signed copy because Andrew had refused to sign.

May you like

I thought the question had been settled.

Then Mara added, “The original draft is missing from my office. Patrick asked for it after Andrew died.”

Related Stories

Other posts