solutions

Chapter 25 - The Guest List

The principal said the guest list had been altered after it was finalized.

Margaret’s name had been written beside Benjamin’s. The person who made the change had not signed it. The school had caught the issue before opening the doors.

I asked them to remove the name and confirm that only approved guests would be admitted. The principal apologized for the oversight.

“Do you think she did it?” I asked Dana.

“I don’t know. The school should check who had access to the list.”

I did not want to accuse Margaret without proof. I also did not want the children worrying about who might appear at the auditorium.

I told Benjamin that the school had found an unauthorized name on the guest list. I did not say who it belonged to.

“Is it handled?” he asked.

“Yes.”

“Then I’m going to sing.”

That evening, Rosa brought the children to the school early. Amelia came straight from work. Dana joined us. Eleanor sat near the aisle. The front row filled with our family.

The performance began.

Benjamin’s first scene went perfectly. He delivered his lines with enough confidence that Mr. Harlan smiled from the wings. During the closing song, Benjamin stepped forward and sang his verse.

His voice carried across the auditorium.

I thought of the first night at Rosa’s house, when Benjamin had slept on the floor outside my door to listen for anyone coming. I thought of the boy at the courthouse asking if he had to forgive his grandfather. I thought of the child who had tried to become an adult because the actual adults had failed him.

He finished the song.

This time, he looked directly at me.

I clapped until my hands hurt.

Afterward, his siblings surrounded him. Caroline gave him a paper star. Lucy hugged his knees. The twins declared that he had been the best singer in the show, though one of them admitted he had missed a line.

Benjamin laughed.

Across the lobby, I saw Margaret.

She was standing just beyond the doors, holding a bouquet. She had not entered the auditorium. A school staff member spoke with her quietly.

I started toward her, then stopped. The children saw her at the same time.

Benjamin’s smile disappeared. Lucy moved behind Caroline.

Margaret lifted the bouquet slightly. “I just wanted to congratulate him.”

The staff member reminded her she was not on the approved guest list.

“I’m his grandmother,” Margaret said.

“I know,” the staff member replied. “You still need approval to attend.”

Margaret looked toward me. “You’re going to keep punishing me forever?”

“I’m keeping the boundary we agreed to.”

“We never agreed to this.”

“The children’s counselor recommended distance.”

She looked at Benjamin. “Sweetheart, I brought you flowers.”

He stepped back.

The staff member asked Margaret to leave. She turned toward the exit, her face flushed.

“I hope you understand what your mother is doing,” she called to Benjamin.

He looked down at the floor.

I moved between them. “That’s enough.”

Margaret left without another word.

After the staff member went back inside, Benjamin let out a shaky breath.

“I was okay until she said that.”

“I’m sorry.”

“She didn’t say congratulations. She said it so everyone would look at me.”

“I know.”

“Could she come to the next show?”

“Not without the counselor’s approval and your agreement.”

He was quiet for a moment. “I don’t think I want her there.”

“That’s enough.”

May you like

When we returned home, a message from Dana was waiting. The school had reviewed its visitor records. Margaret had never signed in. Someone had called the office earlier that day claiming to be an aunt and asked whether Benjamin’s performance had been moved.

The caller had given no name.

Related Stories

Other posts