Chapter 14 - The Empty Seat

The school musical opened on a Friday night.
Our family filled three rows. Rosa brought a small bouquet. Amelia arrived late from a meeting, still wearing her work clothes. Dana had sent a card. The twins wore matching shirts they had decorated themselves, though Caroline had insisted they were not signs.
Benjamin spotted us before the performance began. He looked nervous, but he smiled when he saw the bouquet.
There was one empty seat at the end of our row.
I had saved it for Andrew.
I knew he would not come. I knew keeping a seat for him could turn an ordinary chair into a hurtful reminder. Still, when the auditorium lights dimmed, I could not make myself fill it.
The show began with a chorus of students crossing the stage. Benjamin appeared in the second scene. He spoke clearly and remembered every line. When the song began, he watched the other students, then joined them at the right moment.
His voice was not the loudest in the room.
It was steady.
I looked at the empty chair and imagined Andrew’s hands clapping too early, as he always did. My eyes filled, but I kept my gaze on Benjamin.
Afterward, families crowded the lobby. Caroline ran to her brother first. The twins shouted that they had heard every word. Lucy gave Benjamin the last flower from the bouquet.
“You did it,” I said.
“Yeah.”
“How did it feel?”
“Scary. Then better.”
“That sounds about right.”
A woman waited near the exit, holding a coat over one arm. She had short silver hair and wore a dark green sweater. I recognized her from family gatherings, but it took me a moment to place her.
“Cynthia?” she said. “I’m Eleanor. Andrew’s cousin.”
Eleanor had been absent from the funeral. I remembered Margaret once saying they had “lost touch.”
“I’m sorry I didn’t come sooner,” she said. “Margaret told me you didn’t want anyone from the family around.”
I looked at Benjamin, who was talking with his castmates. “She told you that?”
Eleanor nodded. “She said you were in a fragile state and had asked for privacy.”
“I asked for the children to be left out of a public fight.”
“I understand that now.” She handed me a small envelope. “Andrew left this with me last winter.”
I did not take it immediately.
“Why?”
“He said he wanted you to have it if there was ever trouble over the house. He made me promise not to give it to Patrick.”
The envelope was sealed. My name was written across the front in Andrew’s handwriting.
“I’m sorry,” Eleanor said. “I should have contacted you when he died. But Margaret told me there was nothing to discuss.”
“Did you believe her?”
“I wanted to. She said you had everything under control.”
The words landed hard. People had believed Margaret because she had spoken with confidence, and because believing her was easier than asking questions.
I tucked the envelope into my bag.
Eleanor offered to meet with Dana and explain what she knew. She said she had kept some family documents after Evelyn’s death, including copies of the old occupancy agreement.
“You may want them,” she said.
I thanked her. Then I asked whether she had spoken to Margaret recently.
“Not in months,” she replied. “But she called last week. She wanted to know if I still had Evelyn’s correspondence.”
“What did you tell her?”
“That I did.”
Eleanor’s face tightened. “I think I should tell Dana the rest.”
On the drive home, Benjamin sat beside me in the front passenger seat.
“Was that Dad’s cousin?”
“Yes.”
“Does she like us?”
“I think so.”
He watched the streetlights slide over the window. “I wish Dad could’ve seen tonight.”
“So do I.”
The envelope rested in my bag like a small weight. I waited until the children were asleep before opening it.
Inside was a single page.
Andrew had written: If Patrick says the house was meant to remain in the family, show him what Evelyn actually wanted.
He had not included the document.
May you like
He had written one more line beneath it:
Ask Eleanor about the letter hidden with the garden plans.