solutions

Chapter 3 - The Woman at the Door

Beth arrived forty minutes later carrying an overnight bag she had packed for herself.

“I’m not taking her away,” she said when Tom opened the door. “I’m here to listen.”

That was the first thing she did that embarrassed me.

She had understood Fiona’s request as a need for safety, not a challenge to our authority.

Tom stepped aside.

Beth was forty-one, with Caroline’s dark eyes and a nurse’s habit of noticing everything without making a show of it. She glanced at the bassinets, the envelope of torn pages on the dining table, and my swollen eyes.

“Where is she?”

“Upstairs.”

“Has she eaten?”

Neither of us answered.

Beth went to the kitchen, made toast, sliced an apple, and asked where we kept the peanut butter.

I told her.

She carried the plate upstairs.

For twenty minutes, we heard nothing.

Then Fiona laughed once.

It was a small, startled sound.

Tom gripped the edge of the counter.

“She hasn’t laughed with me like that in weeks.”

I wanted to say something comforting.

Instead, I asked, “When did you last spend time with her alone?”

He opened his mouth, then closed it.

There had been prenatal appointments. Hospital stays. Work deadlines. Night feedings.

All real.

None an answer.

Beth came downstairs carrying the empty plate.

“She wants to stay here tonight if I can sleep in the guest room.”

“Of course,” I said.

Tom nodded.

Beth set the plate in the sink.

“Now tell me what happened to my sister’s book.”

He began with the move, the boxes, the pressure.

Beth let him finish.

Then she said, “That explains your mood. It doesn’t explain your decision.”

He looked wounded.

I recognized the look because I had used it myself: the hurt expression adults sometimes wear when someone refuses to accept remorse as repair.

“I couldn’t look at Caroline’s handwriting every day,” he said.

“Then you put the book somewhere safe.”

“I know.”

“You gave your grief a trash bag and handed the consequences to your daughter.”

His shoulders dropped.

Beth turned toward me.

“And the page?”

“I kept it.”

“Why?”

I answered without softening it.

She listened.

Then she pulled out a chair and sat down heavily.

“Caroline liked you.”

My breath caught.

“We only met twice.”

“She was sick. Twice mattered.”

I remembered bringing soup to their apartment when Tom and I were still coworkers. Caroline had worn a yellow scarf and apologized for the clutter.

“She told me you spoke to Fiona like a person,” Beth said. “You asked about her science project while everybody else whispered about treatment.”

I stared at the table.

“She didn’t predict any of this. She just thought you were kind.”

The word hurt.

Kindness was not something you could claim once and possess forever.

It was a decision you had to keep making.

Beth reached into her purse and took out her phone.

“I might have something.”

Tom looked up sharply.

“What?”

“Photographs. Caroline sent me pictures of the book as she worked on it.”

“Every page?” I asked.

“No. I don’t know how many.”

She scrolled, brow furrowed.

“Old phone backups. Email attachments. I’ll have to look.”

A stair creaked.

Fiona stood halfway down, clutching the surviving page.

“Please don’t say you can get it back if you can’t.”

Beth turned immediately.

“You’re right. I can look. That’s the promise.”

Fiona nodded.

Tom moved toward the staircase.

“Fi, I need to apologize.”

She stiffened.

“You can do it from there.”

He stopped.

“I threw your book away. I knew what it was. Then I let you think you had misplaced it.”

Her grip tightened.

“I was hurting, and I chose something cruel. You didn’t cause it.”

“Why did you keep Mom’s guitar?”

Tom looked toward the living room.

Caroline’s guitar stood in its case behind the armchair. He had not played it in years.

“I don’t know,” he said.

Fiona’s eyes filled.

“You kept the part of her that belonged to you.”

Nobody answered.

There was nothing to add that would make her less right.

She went back upstairs.

That evening, Beth found the first photograph.

It showed Caroline at a kitchen table, a half-finished baby book open beneath her hands.

In the background, barely visible beside the refrigerator, was a cardboard box.

May you like

Across it, in black marker, Caroline had written:

For Fiona, when she asks.

Related Stories

Other posts