solutions

Chapter 4 - The Box Nobody Remembered

Beth enlarged the photograph until the words blurred.

Tom stared at the screen.

“I’ve never seen that box.”

“Neither have I,” Beth said.

“When was this taken?” I asked.

Beth checked the date.

“March 2014.”

Fiona had been a baby then. Caroline had still been healthy.

Upstairs, the floorboards creaked.

We waited until Fiona came down before showing her.

She leaned over Beth’s shoulder.

“Is it still somewhere?”

“We don’t know,” Beth said.

“Grandpa had a storage unit,” Tom offered.

Beth looked at him.

Their father had died two years after Caroline. Most of his things had gone to Beth, but a few boxes remained in a small storage room behind her garage.

“I haven’t opened everything,” she said.

Fiona’s face brightened, then shut down.

“I’m not getting excited.”

“You don’t have to,” I told her.

Beth offered to search the next morning. Fiona asked to go with her.

Tom immediately said, “We should all—”

“No,” Fiona said.

He stopped.

She looked at Beth.

“Just us?”

“Just us.”

After dinner, we sat around the dining table to discuss the damaged triplets’ book.

I had almost postponed it. Fiona had cried enough. I had cried enough.

But leaving the destruction unspoken would have turned compassion into another form of avoidance.

Rachel had sent the photographs in a private download folder. Every page was there.

I put the damaged book on the table.

Fiona stared at the envelope of scraps.

“I’ll pay for a new one.”

“We’ll work out what is fair,” I said. “You don’t owe us money you don’t have.”

“I have birthday money.”

“Some of that can help buy replacement materials. And if you’re willing, you can help assemble the damaged pages again.”

Her mouth tightened.

“So I have to make their book.”

“No. I’m asking you to repair what you damaged. You don’t have to decorate it or pretend you enjoyed doing it.”

She considered that.

“Okay.”

Tom shifted.

“And your phone—”

I looked at him.

He stopped, breathed, and began again.

“We need a consequence connected to what happened. I’m still thinking about what that should look like.”

Fiona watched him cautiously.

Beth said nothing.

For once, Tom let the silence stand.

Later, while Fiona helped Beth make up the guest bed, I found my husband in the laundry room.

“I booked a counseling appointment,” he said.

“For Fiona?”

“For me.”

I leaned against the dryer.

“I need one too.”

He nodded.

“I keep thinking about what she said. The guitar.”

“So do I.”

“I thought getting rid of the book would help us start fresh.”

“She wasn’t asking to start over.”

His eyes reddened.

“I know.”

At two that morning, while I fed Nora, Fiona appeared in the nursery doorway.

“I couldn’t sleep.”

“Want the chair?”

She sat in the rocking chair beside mine.

Nora made a tiny sound around the bottle.

For several minutes, we listened to rain against the window.

Then Fiona asked, “Did you want me before the babies?”

“Yes.”

“Or did I come with Dad?”

The answer mattered too much to rush.

“At first, I met you because of your dad. Then I learned who you were. I learned that you hate bananas, that you read the last page of mysteries first, and that you put worms back in the grass after storms.”

She looked at her knees.

“I still do that.”

“I know. Loving you became its own thing.”

“Then why did you hide the page?”

“Because loving someone doesn’t stop you from being selfish. I wish it did.”

She nodded slowly.

I wanted to reach for her.

I didn’t.

When Nora finished, Fiona stood.

At the door, she paused.

“If there’s a box, I want to open it first.”

“You should.”

“Even if it says something about you.”

My throat tightened.

“Especially then.”

The next morning, Beth drove away with Fiona in the passenger seat.

Three hours later, my phone rang.

Beth didn’t greet me.

“We found it,” she said.

May you like

Then, very quietly:

“But there’s something Tom needs to explain.”

Related Stories

Other posts