Chapter 5 - The Letter He Never Opened

Tom stood beside me when I put Beth on speaker.
“What is it?”
“A letter addressed to you,” she said. “Inside Fiona’s box.”
He went pale.
“I don’t know anything about that.”
“The envelope is sealed.”
“Then why do I need to explain?”
“Because Fiona found another envelope underneath it. That one is empty. It has your name and the words About her book.”
Tom sat down.
I watched his face.
“Beth,” I said, “can you let Fiona decide what she wants shared?”
A pause.
Then Fiona’s voice came through.
“I want him to tell me if Mom asked him to keep it.”
Tom closed his eyes.
“Yes.”
The single word seemed to travel through every room.
“Did you read the letter?” she asked.
“Yes.”
“What did it say?”
He swallowed.
“She asked me to give you the book whenever you missed her. She said you might be angry with her for dying, and the book could remind you that she wanted to stay.”
The line went silent.
Then Fiona said, “You knew.”
“Yes.”
“And when I cried, you knew.”
“Yes.”
Beth took the phone.
“We’re staying here a little longer.”
“Can I talk to her?” Tom asked.
“Not right now.”
After the call ended, he folded forward, elbows on his knees.
“I forgot about the letter.”
“You forgot she wrote it,” I said. “You didn’t forget what you did.”
He looked at me.
There was no anger left in him.
“No.”
I sat across from him, exhausted in a way sleep could not repair.
“I need you to understand something. If this turns into us comforting you because you feel guilty, Fiona loses again.”
He nodded.
“I understand.”
Understanding would have to become behavior. I no longer trusted it as a sentence.
Beth brought Fiona home before dinner.
She carried a small cardboard box against her chest.
Nobody tried to take it.
Inside were a knitted yellow hat, a hospital photograph, three birthday cards Caroline had written in advance, and a little recorder shaped like a silver pebble.
There were also seven printed photographs of baby-book pages.
Seven.
Not the whole book.
Fiona laid them out without speaking.
One showed her first tooth. Another recorded a disastrous attempt at mashed peas. A third had a smeared purple handprint.
The last showed Caroline asleep on a couch, baby Fiona tucked against her chest, Tom sitting on the floor beside them.
He looked younger than thirty-two should have looked.
Happy. Unprepared.
Fiona studied the picture.
“I forgot she slept with her mouth open.”
Beth laughed through tears.
“She would deny that under oath.”
Fiona smiled.
Then she picked up the sealed letter.
“I didn’t open yours,” she told Tom.
“Thank you.”
“That wasn’t for you. I just didn’t want to.”
He nodded.
“I’ll read it privately.”
Fiona carried her box upstairs.
Tom waited until she was gone before opening the envelope.
He read for a long time.
Finally, he passed it to me.
Caroline had written about practical things first. Fiona’s eczema cream. Her fear of dogs that barked behind fences. The fact that she would claim not to be hungry when she was upset.
Then the handwriting grew uneven.
If you love someone again, let Fiona love them differently than she loves me. Don’t make her prove loyalty by staying sad. Don’t make her prove acceptance by forgetting.
At the bottom was one more line.
Please don’t turn my things into a test she can fail.
I laid the letter down.
Tom stared toward the stairs.
“I did exactly that.”
“Yes.”
“What if she never forgives me?”
I heard the fear beneath the question. I had been living with my own version of it all weekend.
“Then you still become someone who tells her the truth.”
That night, we heard Caroline’s voice for the first time in years.
The recorder’s batteries had been replaced.
Through Fiona’s closed door came a crackling laugh.
Then a woman said, “Hello, my wonderful girl.”
Tom stopped halfway up the stairs.
May you like
He sat down on the step.
And this time, he did not knock.