solutions

Chapter 51 - The Children Who Were Supposed to Be Gone

The message arrived nine days after Christmas, while Daniel was teaching Grace how to rescue a zipper from its own fabric.

A woman named Nina Finch had written through Leah's office. She requested a confidential conversation about Andrew Whitmore.

Below her name was a photograph of an eight-year-old boy.

I recognized the shape of his eyes before I read another word.

Andrew is his father. He told Samuel your children died shortly after birth. Samuel has learned that isn't true. Before anyone contacts your family directly, I need help deciding what to tell him.

I sat down so abruptly the chair scraped the floor.

Daniel looked up.

“Rebecca?”

I turned the screen toward him.

Across the room, Grace tugged her coat free and celebrated a small victory. Her living, impatient voice filled the kitchen while I read the word died again.

For eight years, Andrew had denied our children existed.

Apparently, in another house, he had buried them instead.

Daniel waited until Grace went upstairs.

“Do you want me to call Leah?”

“I can do it.”

Then I caught myself.

“Stay, though.”

He pulled out the chair beside mine.

Leah had already verified Nina's identity through her attorney. She had not verified everything in the account. Nina was recovering from a serious car accident at a rehabilitation facility near Baltimore. Her sister, Beth, was caring for Samuel.

“They aren't asking for money,” Leah said. “Or access to your children without your agreement.”

“What are they asking?”

“An adult conversation first.”

I stared at the boy's photograph.

He stood beside a crooked birthday cake, smiling with one front tooth missing. Andrew's hand rested on his shoulder.

The date printed beneath it was five years earlier.

Andrew had known how to stand beside a child.

He had simply chosen a different one.

I closed the image before jealousy could turn an innocent boy into an accusation.

There were undoubtedly people who would call him a secret. I could already hear the language strangers might use if the photograph traveled. I wanted to know whose permission covered it, who had shared it, and whether he understood any of that. Leah confirmed his mother had authorized only this private conversation, not circulation beyond it.

“Ask whether she can meet without Samuel.”

Leah agreed to coordinate with Nina's attorney. There would be no surprise introductions, no photographs passed to the children, and no promises made for them.

When we hung up, Daniel touched my wrist.

“I hate that she had to write that sentence.”

I nodded.

“I hate that some part of me wants to count his birthday candles.”

“Then count them here. You don't have to put that feeling on him.”

The permission nearly undid me.

At dinner, Benjamin described a class debate. Lucas claimed Harbor had developed political opinions. Charlotte demanded evidence. Grace asked whether cats could be registered as independent voters.

I listened too carefully, as if another voice might announce that their ordinary noise was impossible.

Benjamin noticed.

“Did something happen?”

“Something difficult came up about your biological father. I'm checking the facts before we talk about it.”

His face tightened.

“Are we in trouble?”

“No.”

“Is somebody saying we aren't real again?”

The question stole my breath.

Daniel set down his fork.

“Whatever anyone says, it doesn't change who's sitting at this table.”

Charlotte looked between us, suspicious but silent.

After dinner, I stood in the hallway beneath four school portraits. Four different expressions. Benjamin trying to look serious. Lucas failing. Charlotte refusing the photographer's preferred smile. Grace laughing at something outside the frame.

There was no dignified way to feel what I felt.

I put my forehead against the wall and cried.

Daniel found me there and asked before holding me.

Later, Leah forwarded Nina's reply.

Thursday would work. Beth would bring her. Samuel would stay with a trusted neighbor.

Then came one more sentence.

May you like

He keeps asking whether dead children can come back if somebody lied hard enough.

I carried the phone into our bedroom and shut the door. Andrew had made another child responsible for understanding an adult's cruelty. Whatever happened next, I wanted that boy to receive an answer that didn't ask him to disappear too.

Related Stories

Other posts