Chapter 63 - Charlotte's Terms

Charlotte announced her decision while sorting clean socks.
“I'll meet him.”
I looked up slowly enough to avoid making her regret speaking.
“Samuel?”
“No, the president. Yes, Samuel.”
“All right.”
“At the park. Not here. And nobody says this proves anything.”
“We can arrange that.”
She paired two socks with unnecessary force.
“Also, Grace can't narrate my emotional development.”
I pressed my lips together.
“I'll discuss the general importance of privacy with everyone.”
“Thank you.”
The meeting happened on a cool Saturday with Beth and me nearby. Benjamin came at Charlotte's request. Lucas and Grace stayed with Daniel.
Samuel arrived carrying the star-covered notebook.
Charlotte noticed immediately.
“Did the pages tear?”
“Not with scissors.”
“Good.”
They walked toward a climbing frame while Benjamin investigated a bench with a loose plank. He seemed relieved to have something uncontroversial to examine.
At first, Charlotte asked Samuel practical questions. School. Favorite lunch. Whether he understood that Harbor belonged to himself and merely tolerated us.
Samuel answered solemnly.
Then a younger child dropped a toy truck from the climbing frame. Charlotte retrieved it before it reached a puddle.
Samuel watched her hand it back.
“You look like him,” he said.
I felt Beth tense beside me.
Charlotte stood still.
“Like Andrew?”
Samuel nodded, immediately worried.
“I'm sorry.”
“Don't be sorry for having eyes.”
Benjamin looked toward them but didn't intervene.
Charlotte sat on the edge of the low platform.
“I know I do.”
Samuel joined her after a moment.
“I used to think that meant he'd come back.”
“What did?”
“Looking like him. Mom said I had his smile.”
Charlotte stared across the playground.
“I used to try not to.”
For a while, neither child spoke.
I stood far enough away to hear only pieces, resisting the urge to make the moment safer by taking it over.
Samuel opened the notebook. A folded photograph slipped from the back cover.
The fishing picture.
He grabbed it quickly, then looked at Charlotte.
“I can put it away.”
She examined his face.
“Do you like it?”
He nodded.
“Then don't throw it out because I don't have one.”
Beth turned away, wiping her eyes.
Charlotte pointed toward a distant path.
“There's a duck pond. The ducks are rude.”
Samuel smiled.
“Can we see?”
She stood.
“Benjamin, you're coming. Ducks respect numbers.”
He laughed and followed them.
At the pond, Charlotte bought a portion of the approved feed from the dispenser and divided it among them. Samuel tried to give her his share. She shook her head and showed him how to scatter it without encouraging a battle. Benjamin informed them that the ducks had not accepted the peace terms. Samuel laughed, throwing feed badly. Charlotte corrected his technique, then demonstrated something worse. I watched three children complain about ducks and let that be the story for the afternoon.
On the drive home, Charlotte watched the passing houses.
“Did you hear?”
“Some of it.”
“You're not going to tell everybody?”
“No.”
She nodded.
After a while, she said, “He's little.”
“He is.”
“I thought he'd feel like proof.”
“Proof of what?”
“That Andrew could do it if he wanted. But mostly he feels like a kid who doesn't know where to put his hands.”
I kept my eyes on the road while my own vision blurred.
“That sounds like you saw him.”
She shrugged.
“Don't make it weird.”
At home, Grace took one look at her and wisely asked whether she wanted a sandwich.
Charlotte said yes.
That evening, Nina called to thank us. I told her the visit had gone well, but the children's private conversation belonged to them.
She accepted that.
Later, Charlotte placed another notebook on the kitchen counter. This one had plain blue covers.
“For when he fills the first.”
May you like
I nodded as if she had asked me to buy milk.
After she went upstairs, Daniel found me smiling at the notebook. I explained only what she had chosen to share. He touched its cover and said nothing for a moment. Then he asked whether we should keep spare scissors with the games. I laughed. Practical affection had become one of our household specialties, and apparently Charlotte was developing her own version of it.