Chapter 75 - Nina’s Stand

Nina Finch’s new apartment in Silver Spring was bright, practical, and devoid of the heavy mahogany gloom that had haunted every Whitmore property. Wide doorways allowed her wheelchair to glide easily from the kitchen to the sunroom, where rows of potted ferns flourished beneath broad skylights.
When Leah and I arrived on Saturday morning, Samuel met us at the door. At ten, he was shooting up like a reed, his dark hair falling across his forehead in the exact pattern of Benjamin’s. He wore a Baltimore Orioles T-shirt and held a sketchbook tucked under his arm.
"Aunt Rebecca," he said, stepping aside with the polite formality he had learned from Beth. "Mom’s in the study. She made coffee."
"Thank you, Samuel," I said, reaching down to squeeze his shoulder. "How was your soccer game?"
"We won four to two," he beamed. "Ben came. He sat on the bench and kept score for us."
Hearing that Benjamin was spending his Saturday morning quietly cheering for his half-brother in the midst of this digital firestorm nearly brought me to my knees. The bond between these boys had not been forged by blood or legal decrees; it had been grown, inch by inch, through shared patience and honest conversations.
Nina was sitting behind a low desk, her laptop open, her reading glasses pushed up into her hair. Beside her sat Beth, who looked ready to drive a truck through Arthur Vance’s front office.
"I saw the GoFundMe page," Nina said without preamble, gesturing for us to sit. Her voice was firm, carrying none of the hesitant, broken cadence from four years ago. "He included Samuel."
My heart stopped. "What do you mean?"
Nina turned her screen toward us. Beneath the photo of Benjamin was an update posted just six hours earlier: “A father’s love knows no bounds. I am fighting not only for my quadruplets in Annapolis, but to restore the broken bond with my youngest son, Samuel, who is being kept from me by an orchestrated family campaign.”
"The audacity of this man," Beth fumed, slamming a mug onto a coaster. "Andrew hasn't called Samuel since Christmas of 2024. He hasn't sent a birthday card. He owes fourteen months of court-ordered child support, which we didn't even bother enforcing because we just wanted him out of our lives!"
"He’s using Samuel to paint himself as a family man who was systematically alienated by two bitter women," Leah analyzed, tapping her pen against her legal pad. "It’s a standard sympathy play. If he shows a pattern of alleged parental alienation across two different relationships, it makes Rebecca look coordinated and punitive."
Nina leaned back in her chair, her jaw set with an iron resolve that reminded me of my own reflection in the mirror.
"He thinks I’m still the fragile girl in the rehabilitation hospital who can be terrified into silence," Nina said coldly. "He thinks because I was in that car accident, because I took three years to learn how to walk again, that I will hide under a blanket while he drags my son into his fundraising scam."
"Nina," I said gently, "you don't have to put yourself in the line of fire. Your custody order is ironclad. He has zero visitation rights until he completes supervised therapy, which he hasn't even attended."
"No," Nina said, looking me dead in the eye. "For years, Rebecca, you carried the burden of telling the truth while I hid behind my injuries. I let you be the villain in the newspapers while I stayed safe in the background. That ends today."
She reached into a side drawer and pulled out a certified manila envelope stamped by the Maryland Child Support Enforcement Administration.
"Two weeks ago, my forensic accountant completed an asset search on Andrew’s post-release filings," Nina said. "He told his probation officer that he was indigent, working minimum-wage retail to survive. But three months ago, Arthur Vance’s operating account transferred sixty-five thousand dollars into a newly formed LLC registered in Delaware under the name Old Dominion Consulting. The sole managing member of that LLC is Andrew Whitmore."
Leah sat up straight, her eyes sharpening like a hawk catching movement in the brush. "Where did Vance get sixty-five thousand dollars?"
"From Eleanor Whitmore’s personal checking account," Nina replied, sliding the financial tracing sheet across the table. "Eleanor didn't just hire the lawyer, Leah. She’s paying Andrew a monthly retainer through a corporate front to keep this litigation alive. It’s not about parental rights. It’s an illegal maintenance scheme to harass us."
Leah picked up the document, her mouth curving into the predatory smile of an elite litigator who had just found the opposing counsel’s jugular.
"Under Maryland Rule 1-341, filing an unmeritorious claim for an improper purpose—specifically using third-party funds to circumvent a prior bad-faith finding—carries mandatory attorney fee sanctions," Leah said, her voice singing with professional triumph. "And Eleanor’s supervised release terms from the foundation settlement strictly forbade her from transferring assets to Andrew without notifying the federal monitor."
"She violated her federal probation," I whispered, the realization washing over me like ice water.
"She blew right through it," Nina confirmed. "And I am signing a sworn affidavit attaching this audit to your opposition motion on Monday morning."
I looked across the table at this woman who had once been Andrew’s second secret, who had arrived in my life broken by grief and physical trauma. She was no longer a victim picking up the pieces. She was an ally standing shoulder-to-shoulder on the ramparts.
May you like
"Thank you, Nina," I said softly.
Nina reached across the desk and took my hand, her grip surprisingly strong. "He buried your babies in his stories, Rebecca. He tried to erase my son in his greed. Let’s make sure he never speaks for any of them again."