solutions

Chapter 64 - The Answer Benjamin Read Twice

Benjamin sent his letter after three counseling sessions and two revisions.

He removed nothing because an adult found it uncomfortable. He changed what he wanted to change, decided what response he was willing to receive, and used the channel Leah arranged with Andrew's counsel.

He did not ask his siblings to sign it.

The answer took seventeen days.

I knew because he counted without admitting he was counting.

When Leah confirmed it had arrived, Benjamin chose to read it first with the counselor. Daniel drove him. I waited at home, reorganizing a drawer that had committed no offense.

They returned before dinner.

Benjamin went upstairs to put away his coat, though he could have hung it by the door.

Daniel found me beside the drawer.

“He wants to show you after he eats.”

“Okay.”

“It was hard.”

I nodded.

Dinner lasted longer than usual. Lucas described a robot that turned only left. Charlotte suggested that sounded like a political problem. Grace asked whether anyone had seen her good scissors.

Nobody rushed Benjamin toward the thing he carried.

Afterward, he handed me the letter.

Andrew had answered the opening question directly.

Nothing was wrong with you. I chose what was easier for me, then told stories that made those choices sound unavoidable.

I read the sentence twice.

He acknowledged visiting Samuel while ignoring the children whose existence threatened his preferred life. He did not claim he had loved them equally in secret.

Benjamin deserved a better father than an invisible feeling.

The letter admitted that too.

Near the end, Andrew wrote that Samuel's presence should not be used to ask anyone for forgiveness. He would answer further factual questions through the same channel if Benjamin wanted.

There was no request for a visit.

I set the pages down carefully.

“What do you think?” I asked.

Benjamin stared at his hands.

“I believe that part.”

“Which part?”

“That it was easier. I don't think it makes him good.”

“It doesn't have to.”

His chin trembled.

“I wanted something I could fix.”

I moved beside him when he reached for me.

For years, he had carried the possibility that a better version of himself might have persuaded Andrew to stay.

An honest answer removed that hope as well as the blame.

It hurt in both directions.

Later, Benjamin asked whether he could keep the letter somewhere private.

“Of course.”

“Not with the legal stuff.”

“No.”

Daniel helped him find a small box with a clasp. Benjamin put the letter inside and placed it on his own shelf.

Nobody else asked to read it.

Driving home from counseling, Daniel bought the kind of bread Benjamin liked without asking whether he wanted to talk. My son mentioned that later. He said it had helped that the car could be quiet without feeling angry. I thanked Daniel that night, and he shrugged. Sometimes, he said, a kid just needed a ride, lunch, and somebody who could wait. I kissed him, grateful for the knowledge that patience could be learned and offered.

The following weekend, he wanted to see Samuel again. Baseball this time, on television, with snacks that did not require a supervised discussion.

Beth and Nina agreed to a short visit after we checked everyone's plans.

Charlotte stayed for the first inning. Lucas criticized the scoreboard graphics. Grace drew elaborate uniforms for Harbor.

Samuel sat beside Benjamin and asked questions about every rule.

Benjamin answered patiently until the third repeated question.

Then he said, “You have to watch the screen sometimes.”

Samuel grinned.

The ordinary irritation felt like a gift.

That night, Benjamin found Daniel taking out the trash.

“I still call you Dad,” he said abruptly.

Daniel stopped.

“I wasn't keeping score.”

“I know. I'm saying it anyway.”

Daniel nodded, his face changing.

May you like

“Then I'm glad to hear it.”

They carried the bins to the curb together. I watched from the doorway without interrupting. At the street, Benjamin said something that made Daniel laugh. The letter upstairs held an answer about the past. Downstairs, my son was making plans with the father who knew where his baseball glove belonged, how he took his toast, and when to wait until he was ready to talk.

Related Stories

Other posts