Chapter 54 - The Boy at the Round Table

The first meeting happened in a counselor's office with a round table and a basket of battered toy animals.
Benjamin and Grace chose to attend. Lucas wanted to wait until afterward. Charlotte wanted no details unless she asked.
We honored all four answers.
Nina joined by video from the rehabilitation facility. Beth brought Samuel and remained beside him until he indicated she could move her chair.
He wore a green sweatshirt with a dinosaur whose teeth had cracked in the wash.
For a moment, nobody knew where to look.
Then Grace pointed at the dinosaur.
“Lucas would say that's anatomically irresponsible.”
Samuel glanced down.
“Because of the arms?”
“Probably. He has opinions.”
Samuel smiled.
It changed his face so suddenly that I had to look away.
The resemblance was real. So was the difference. This boy pressed his lips together before speaking, watched Beth for reassurance, and kept one sneaker tucked behind the other.
He was himself.
The counselor helped them exchange ordinary information. Favorite foods. School subjects. Whether Harbor was a reasonable name for a cat.
“Better than Admiral Waffles,” Grace said.
Samuel laughed.
Benjamin asked whether he liked baseball.
“Not playing. I get scared of the ball.”
“That's sensible,” Benjamin said. “It comes at your face.”
Beth covered a smile.
For fifteen minutes, the room belonged to children becoming less unfamiliar.
Samuel asked whether being the same age meant Benjamin and Grace liked everything together. Grace answered so emphatically that Beth laughed. Benjamin explained that Lucas enjoyed machines, Charlotte enjoyed being right, and Grace enjoyed explaining why everybody needed to behave better. Grace kicked his shoe under the table. Samuel watched them with surprise. For once, resemblance led to a joke instead of an unbearable question about who had been wanted.
Then Samuel reached into his pocket.
“Can I show you something?”
The counselor asked what it was before he unfolded it.
A photograph, worn along its creases.
Andrew helping Samuel hold a fishing rod.
Benjamin stopped moving.
“Dad took me,” Samuel said. “I was little. I don't remember the fish, though.”
Grace looked toward me.
Samuel's smile faded.
“Am I not supposed to have it?”
The counselor answered before shame could settle.
“You can have a photograph of something you remember. Other people can have different feelings about the same person.”
Benjamin stared at the picture.
“Did he call you buddy?”
Samuel nodded.
The silence changed.
I felt something sharp beneath my ribs. Benjamin had spent years pretending he didn't care whether the man who made him knew how to say his name.
Now he was asking about a nickname.
The counselor offered a break.
Benjamin stood immediately.
I followed him into the hall after checking that Grace wanted to remain with Beth and the counselor.
He leaned against the wall.
“I don't hate him.”
“Samuel?”
He nodded, his jaw trembling.
“I just wanted that too.”
I put my arm around him when he leaned toward me.
“I know.”
“Does that make me selfish?”
“No.”
We stayed there until his breathing slowed.
He chose to return for a short goodbye. Samuel looked terrified when we entered.
Benjamin sat down.
“I got upset about grown-up stuff,” he said. “You didn't do anything.”
Samuel unfolded the photograph once, then put it away.
“Okay.”
Grace asked whether next time they could bring a game.
The counselor reminded everyone that another meeting could be considered later. No promises needed today.
In the car, Benjamin asked for music. Grace watched the road.
At home, Daniel met us with grilled cheese and no questions at the door.
That night, I told him about the fishing photograph after the children slept.
“He knew how,” I whispered. “That's the part I can't stop hearing.”
Daniel sat beside me.
“Yes,” he said. “He did.”
May you like
I cried without having to defend the unfairness of it.
When I finally went upstairs, Benjamin's bedroom light was still on. I knocked. He let me sit while he sorted baseball cards. We talked about the players, not the photograph, until he yawned. At his door, he asked whether next time Samuel could choose the music on the drive home. I said we could discuss it when there was a next time.