Chapter 76 - The Deposition Trap

The conference room of Vance & Associates in downtown Annapolis was designed to intimidate. Chrome-edged tables, floor-to-ceiling windows overlooking the state capitol dome, and a battery of video cameras set on tripods to record every twitch, hesitation, and tear.
Arthur Vance sat at the head of the table, flanked by Andrew Whitmore.
It was the first time I had sat across from Andrew in an enclosed room since the day he walked away from the Annapolis courthouse eight years ago. He wore a crisp, tailored navy suit—undoubtedly purchased with Eleanor’s illicit consulting money—but the arrogance of his youth had curdled into something greasy and hollow. The patrician jawline was blurred by alcohol, and his eyes darted constantly toward the cameras, checking his angles like an aging actor who knew his lighting was bad.
"We are on the record," the court reporter announced, her fingers hovering above the steno machine. "Deposition of Captain Andrew Whitmore in the matter of Sullivan v. Whitmore, petition to vacate adoption decree."
Leah Bennett leaned forward, her voice crisp, modulated, and entirely free of emotional inflection.
"Captain Whitmore, in your sworn petition, paragraph fourteen, you state that on April 12, 2023, you executed the voluntary consent to adoption under 'intolerable duress and threats of professional annihilation.' Is that your testimony today?"
Andrew cleared his throat, adjusting his silk tie. "It is. Commander Sullivan made it clear through her intermediaries that if I did not sign the consent, she would ensure my military dismissal was converted into a dishonorable discharge, stripping me of every civilian credential I had left."
"I see," Leah said, turning a page. "And who were these 'intermediaries'?"
"Her attorneys. Her family. The social pressure was coordinated."
"Captain Whitmore, at the time you signed the consent, you had already been convicted of three felony counts of wire fraud and one count of embezzlement from the Whitmore Veteran Relief Foundation, correct?"
Vance waved a hand. "Objection. Relevance."
"It goes directly to the state of his professional credentials, Counsel," Leah shot back without looking at him. "Captain Whitmore, were you not already dismissed from the United States Army with an Other Than Honorable discharge six months prior to signing the adoption papers?"
Andrew’s jaw twitched. "The administrative appeal was pending."
"An appeal that was denied unanimously by the Army Board for Correction of Military Records forty-eight hours later, correct?"
"I believed I still had a career," Andrew muttered.
"Let’s talk about your relationship with the children," Leah continued, sliding a manila folder toward him. "Between their birth on September 14, 2010, and your Christmas Eve dinner on December 24, 2018, how many times did you physically see Benjamin, Lucas, Charlotte, or Grace?"
"Objection!" Vance snapped. "The historical record prior to the adoption is irrelevant to the question of duress."
"The historical record defines whether parental rights existed in substance or merely on paper," Leah retorted. "Answer the question, Captain."
Andrew stared at the folder, his collar visibly choking him. "Zero."
"In those eight years, how many child support payments did you voluntarily remit to the Maryland Child Support Administration?"
"I was under the impression—"
"A number, Captain Whitmore. One? Five? Ten?"
"Zero," Andrew whispered.
"And when Grace Sullivan underwent emergency pediatric cardiovascular surgery at Johns Hopkins at fourteen months of age, did you receive a certified notice requesting family medical history?"
"I... my office handled the mail."
"Your mother handled the mail," Leah corrected. "And you approved stamping that notice Refused—Unauthorized Solicitation, did you not?"
Andrew looked toward his attorney, but Vance was furiously scribbling notes, offering no lifeline. The red recording light on the camera blinked steadily, drinking in every drop of sweat forming at Andrew’s hairline.
"I made mistakes," Andrew said, his voice rising, trying to regain the polished cadence of an officer. "I was young. The burden was impossible. But after my release from Leavenworth, I tried to make amends. I wanted to be in their lives! And Rebecca systematically froze me out. She introduced another man into my home, gave him my children’s names, and used her position to erase me!"
"Did she?" Leah smiled—a cold, terrifying flash of white teeth. She opened a second, thicker binder. "Let’s look at Exhibit D. This is a certified transcript from the Maryland Department of Public Safety and Correctional Services. On November 4, 2023, while incarcerated, you met with your then-counsel, Mr. David Ross. Do you recall that meeting?"
Andrew frowned. "I had many meetings."
"In that meeting, according to your own attorney’s preserved billing memorandum produced under our subpoena duces tecum, you stated—and I quote: 'If I sign the adoption waiver now, does that prevent Rebecca from going after my portion of the 1974 trust when my father dies?'"
The temperature in the room plummeted forty degrees.
Andrew’s face went the color of skim milk. His hands, resting on the mahogany table, began to visibly shake.
"That’s... that’s attorney-client privilege," Vance stammered, his face turning an apoplectic shade of purple. "That document is protected! This is an outrage!"
"The crime-fraud exception applies, Mr. Vance," Leah said, her voice dropping into a register of absolute authority. "When a client consults an attorney to facilitate a fraudulent transfer or perjury, the privilege dissolves. You filed a sworn affidavit stating Captain Whitmore signed under emotional duress. This billing record proves he signed under calculated financial strategy—he surrendered his children intentionally to insulate his inheritance from child support judgments!"
"You set me up," Andrew rasped, lunging half an inch out of his chair, pointing a trembling finger across the table at me. "You’ve been tracking my grandfather’s trust for years! You planned this!"
May you like
I didn't flinch. I didn't raise my voice. I leaned forward, looking into the eyes of the man who had abandoned four dying infants to preserve his social calendar, and delivered the coup de grâce.
"I didn't need to plan anything, Andrew," I said softly. "You wrote down your own greed. We just made sure the court had the carbon copy."